Netizen Report: Scholars in Colombia, Kazakhstan face legal woes for sharing research.

Netizen Report: Scholars in Colombia, Kazakhstan Face Legal Woes for Sharing Research

Netizen Report: Scholars in Colombia, Kazakhstan Face Legal Woes for Sharing Research

Future Tense
The Citizen's Guide to the Future
July 1 2015 4:35 PM

Netizen Report: Scholars in Colombia, Kazakhstan Face Legal Woes for Sharing Research

Opponents of Ecuadorian President Rafael Correa clash with policemen in Quito as they protest against a bill that would increase inheritance taxes, June 10, 2015. The protests coincided with Internet connectivity problems.

Photo by Juan Cevallos/AFP/Getty Images

The Netizen Report offers an international snapshot of challenges, victories, and emerging trends in Internet rights around the world. It originally appears each week on Global Voices Advocacy. Ellery Roberts Biddle, Lisa Ferguson, Hae-in Lim, and Sarah Myers West contributed to this report.

GVA logo

In October, a Colombian graduate student will go on trial for sharing an academic paper online.* The paper’s author pressed copyright violation charges against Diego Gomez for posting his research on the document-sharing website Scribd, despite the fact that Gomez was trying only to share the paper’s findings with his classmates and that he earned no profit in doing so. The 27-year-old could face a maximum sentence of eight years in prison.


The case has hit a nerve among digital rights advocates across the Americas, where the United States has a disproportionately broad influence over regional copyright policy. Colombia's free trade agreement with the United States, originally signed in 2006, required that the country adopt copyright policies that closely mirror the U.S. copyright regime. Laws passed over the past three years have expanded criminal penalties for copyright infringement to include possible prison sentences and monetary fines. To make matters worse, Colombia lacks important countermeasures to these restrictions, such as exceptions for fair use.

Gomez, who has since moved to Costa Rica to complete his degree in wildlife preservation, demonstrates how Colombia’s newly tightened copyright regime may stifle academic freedom and innovation. Gomez is working actively with Bogotá digital rights group Fundación Karisma to call attention to the case. In a recent appeal for support, he wrote (as translated by Global Voices):

If open access were the rule and not the exception when it comes to the publication of scientific research, its impact would be greater and cases like mine wouldn’t exist. There would be no doubt that that what’s right is for this knowledge to circulate in order to benefit the rest of the world. Meanwhile in Europe, academic publisher Elsevier is suing Kazakh science researcher Alexandra Elbakyan over Sci-Hub, an online platform she launched in an effort to collect and share research papers free of charge. She began the project in 2011 in a simple effort to increase access to scientific and medical research in Kazakhstan and other countries where universities often do not have access to large Western-owned research databases. In an interview with TorrentFreak, Elbakyan explained SciHub’s role among researchers in Russia and Central Asia:

The software immediately became popular among Russian researchers. There was no big idea behind the project, like “make all information free” or something like that. We just needed to read all these papers to do our research. Despite the fact that Sci-Hub is a free platform with no commercial gains for its operators, academic publisher Elsevier is suing for millions of dollars in damages. But Elbakyan has no plans to back down. “At this time I either have to prove we have the full right to do this or risk being executed like other ‘pirates,’ ” she says, referencing Aaron Swartz, the open-knowledge advocate and former MIT student who took his own life while facing possible incarceration for allegedly downloading articles from an academic database without authorization. “If Elsevier manages to shut down our projects or force them into the darknet, that will demonstrate an important idea: that the public does not have the right to knowledge.”


Media attacks and spotty mobile service in Ecuador
Ecuadorians in the cities of Quito and Guayaquil experienced lapses in mobile connectivity during recent protests over proposed increases on inheritance and capital gains taxes. The cause of the connectivity problems remains unclear. Some users speculated they might have been due to network saturations, while others suspected the possible use of signal jammers. In addition, some Ecuadorian media, including, LaRepublica, and Teleamazonas, suffered distributed denial-of-service attacks that forced their websites offline.

Vietnamese human rights lawyer released from prison
Vietnamese human rights lawyer and blogger Le Quoc Quan was released from prison June 27 after serving a 30-month prison sentence for charges of tax evasion. Quan has been arbitrarily detained multiple times by Vietnamese authorities for continuing his human rights work, leading the United Nations to condemn the violation of his right to free expression and a fair trial.

Citing weakened privacy laws, tech industry says cheerio to the U.K.
A growing number of companies are leaving the United Kingdom in favor of the Netherlands over concerns about the government’s plans to weaken privacy laws and require backdoors in technology products and services. In particular, company leaders have cited the planned abolition of the Human Rights Act and the revival of the Snooper’s Charter—which would expand the already-broad surveillance powers of GCHQ, the U.K. intelligence agency—as threats to their business interests.

Australia is no safe haven for the humble torrent freak
Australia passed a new law that would make it easier for copyright holders to obtain court orders to block websites that either have the primary purpose of infringing copyright or “facilitate” its infringement. The Senate rejected a series of safeguards that would have provided affected parties with a right of appeal and protected virtual private networks, which now could be blocked if they face claims their services are designed to make infringing on copyright easier.

Dutch court asks Facebook to bare all
A Dutch court ordered Facebook to provide access to its servers for an external expert to verify it has no information that could help a young woman determine who published a sex video of her without her consent. Facebook argued whoever posted the video used a fake account that was deleted before the company received any request for user data. “Facebook has a legal obligation to provide the information because the unknown person acted illegally and the information cannot be obtained elsewhere,” the court ruled.

New Research
Who Has Your Back? Protecting Your Data From Government Requests”—Electronic Frontier Foundation

*Correction, July 1, 2015: This post originally misstated that Diego Gomez would go on trial June 30. His trial was previously scheduled for June 30 but has been postponed until October.

Future Tense is a partnership of SlateNew America, and Arizona State University.