When Amy Schumer, Bill Hader, and Judd Apatow stopped by Bravo’s Watch What Happens: Live last night to promote Trainwreck, host Andy Cohen decided to play director. For a game called Clubhouse Playhouse, Cohen had the trio re-enact this classic Real Housewives of New York City kerfuffle.

Apatow and Hader outed themselves almost immediately as having never actually seen Housewives, with Apatow playing LuAnn de Lesseps—better known as the Countess—with a thick north Jersey accent, something that would no doubt have horrified the real de Lesseps. Schumer even interrupts the sketch to tell Hader he sounds nothing like Bethenny Frankel. To be fair, Schumer’s own Sonja Morgan impression is pretty spot-on—but it’s not nearly as funny as Apatow’s Countess.