Slate's Culture Blog

Follow Friday: If You Come at the King, You Best Love The Wire

omar

Michael K. Williams as Omar Little on The Wire.

“I don't read books. The Great American Novel has been written... and it's called The Wire.”

And with that first tweet begins the timeline of @OKCLovesTheWire (or should I say, “The Great American Twitter Account”?). The feed is simply a compilation of things users on the dating website OK Cupid say about the HBO drama.

Such as:

Read More »

 

Fact-Checking Rampart: Is This Really “the Most Corrupt Cop” in Movie History?

Official poster for Rampart

Both the poster and the trailer for the crime drama Rampart, out today, loudly herald its LAPD antihero as “the most corrupt cop you’ve ever seen on screen.” The marketing gimmick is effective, just like the heavy metal guitars the trailer employs to make even taking a dip in the swimming pool seem thrillingly sinister. But the marketers could also use some perspective.

The corruptness of Hollywood’s most corrupt cops cannot be underestimated. Woody Harrelson’s Officer Dave Brown is indeed a pretty bad and deeply troubled dude. He’s racist, ill-tempered, and a womanizer. But his corruption is a case of mild dyspepsia compared to the rabid rampages that are S.O.P. for many other movie cops.

Hollywood likes its cops over the top. Several actors have given their most scenery-chewing performances as police officers (usually as members of the LAPD, the local force for most moviemakers, and a department familiar with real-life scandal itself). They plant evidence, take out other cops that get in the way, and shoot at dead gangsters because “their souls are still dancing.”

Here are 10 cops more corrupt than Harrelson’s Dave Brown, along with an internal affairs-style report on the estimable misdeeds of each. Eat your heart out, Officer Brown.

120210_BB_CopSlideShow

 

Has Liz Lemon Become “Dumbass Homer”?

lizhomer

Liz Lemon (L), Homer Simpson (R).

Left: Tina Fey as Liz Lemon on '30 Rock.' Photo by: Ali Goldstein/NBC. Right: Homer Simpson on 'The Simpsons.'© 2006 FOX Broadcasting. All Rights Reserved.

Yesterday, Linda Holmes published a piece on the NPR blog Monkey See called “The Incredible Shrinking Liz Lemon: From Woman to Little Girl,” arguing that over the course of six seasons, 30 Rock has transformed Tina Fey’s character from a competent career woman (albeit one with some serious personal failings) into an infantilized woman-child in thrall to Alec Baldwin’s network-running big daddy, Jack Donaghy.

She’s right, though the problem goes beyond the character of Liz Lemon.

Read More »

 

Does Time Magazine Think Americans Are Stupid?

timecovers

You may notice something striking about this week’s American edition of Time magazine.

While readers in Asia, Europe, and the South Pacific—really, the rest of the Time-reading world—confront a serious profile about Italian Prime Minister Mario Monti and his role in the euro crisis, Americans are in for a special treat: a cover story called “The Surprising Science of Animal Friendships*.” (The asterisk leads to a footnote at the bottom of the cover that says, “BFFs are not just for humans anymore.”) With not one but two adorable dogs against a hot-pink background, this week’s Time really signifies the editors’ staunch commitment to serious, hard-hitting journalism, even if it means risking unpopularity.

Sarcasm aside: This is not the first time this has happened. In fact, Time faced ridicule for giving the rest of the world a cover story on the Arab protests while feeding Americans a cartoon cover about “Why Anxiety Is Good For You” only two months ago.

timecovers2

Time’s conviction that Americans only want to read feel-good puff pieces appears to be far stronger than any desire on the publisher’s part to sell itself as an important U.S. news source.

 

Is Mad Men More Careful About Language Than Downton Abbey?

110207_BB_MadMen
A still of Elisabeth Moss, Jon Hamm, and Christina Hendricks on Mad Men.

Yesterday, I posted a new video by Slate contributor and Visual Thesaurus executive producer Ben Zimmer, detailing apparent linguistic anachronisms on Downton Abbey. Zimmer has now posted his explanation for each of the offending phrases—and he happens to address some of the questions raised by commenters on yesterday’s post.

Multiple commenters pointed out that “uppity” was in use by 1880, well before Downton Abbey takes place. However, Zimmer says that “uppity” did not come to England until well after it first appeared in the U.S.

On the American side, examples can be found back to 1880 (from the Uncle Remus tales of Joel Chandler Harris), but it did not make its way to the U.K. until much later: again, the Google Ngram Viewer identifies when it came into use in American and British English. (Uppish was an available British equivalent for "presumptuously arrogant.")

Zimmer’s post also links to a previous video he made, addressing apparent anachronisms in the first three seasons of Mad Men. While Zimmer doesn’t come out and say so, reading these posts side-by-side leads me to believe that the writers of Mad Men are more careful about such things than Julian Fellowes and crew. (Though, I admit, having Joan say “the medium is the message” in 1960 is probably the most egregious error on either show; Matthew Weiner himself owned up to that one.) Of course, Mad Men is set in a much more recent era, so perhaps Fellowes just faces a greater degree of difficulty.

What do you think? Watch the Mad Men video below. And, in case you missed it, the Downton Abbey video can be found here.

 

This Picture Is Worth 20 Words: Prince Harry Edition

Welcome back to Slate’s caption contest. All we’re going to tell you about this photo is that it was taken itoday. Post your captions—20 words or fewer—in the comments section. (And watch that word count! We’ve been getting some great entries that are longer than 20 words and must therefore be disqualified).

Prince Harry Caption Contest
Michelle Caption Contest

The winner:  Black-6

Here’s the problem. Once I loosen this, you’ll be able to blink again.

The runner up: themichaelrudd

Bachmann hopes the new look, complete with Ronald Reagan henna neck tattoo, will ignite early interest in a 2016 campaign.

The actual caption: 

Representative Michele Bachmann, a Republican from Minnesota and former GOP presidential candidate, left, is prepped for an interview with Al Hunt, executive editor for Washington at Bloomberg via Getty Images News, right, in Washington, D.C., U.S., on Friday, Feb. 3, 2012. (Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

 

Romney’s Longtime Hometown Used to Symbolize “The New Upper Class”

79530951
Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney and his wife Ann Romney in Belmont, Massachusetts.

Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images

Charles Murray, one of the co-authors of The Bell Curve, has a new book out, this time tackling what he sees as an essentially cultural divide between a new upper class and a new lower class. While discussing a class divide at all might seem anathema to many Republicans, the book’s emphasis on morals and mores has, predictably, been mostly heralded by conservatives and pilloried by liberals. Among its conservative champions is David Brooks, who wrote in The New York Times that he will be “shocked if there’s another book this year as important as Charles Murray’s Coming Apart.”

Brooks presumably noticed the bit near the beginning where Murray praises him for bringing an “anthropologist’s eye” and “wickedly funny pen” to his own consideration of “the new upper class” in Bobos in Paradise, as well the passage where Murray specifically directs readers to chapter six of Bobos for a fuller consideration of religion among this particular demographic (not to mention the handful of other positive Brooks citations).

Even without these, though, the two are natural bedfellows: Both radically simplify specific places in order to get over broad arguments about cultural divides.

Read More »

 

Did You See This? Downton Abbey Anachronisms

Downton Abbey. Series Two.
Dan Stevens as Matthew Crawley and Zoe Boyle as Lavinia Swire.

Photograph Nick Briggs. Courtesy of © Carnival Film & Television Limited 2011 for MASTERPIECE

If you're as obsessive about Downton Abbey as the members of Slate's TV Club, you may have read (or even noticed yourself) that the language used on the show does not always seem to be entirely historically accurate. Over in the show's home country, the subject was actually covered in the newspaper—well, the Daily Mail, anyway, which ran a piece with the headline, "Get knotted! Downton Abbey talks its way into trouble with use of modern slang." The piece quotes an editor of the Oxford English Dictionary, who says that some of the colloquialisms on the show seem "quite wrong."

Now Ben Zimmer, a Slate contributor, has created a video for the website he executive produces, the Visual Thesaurus, detailing all the seeming linguistic anachronisms from Season 2 of the show, from "just saying" to "I couldn't care less." See them all below, and check out the Visual Thesaurus in the days ahead for explanations as to why these uses of language are probably historically inaccurate.

Note: The video goes all the way through episode 8, and so may contain spoilers for American viewers. Each anachronism receives its own title card, so you can choose to watch just the first few.

 

Obama Pretends to Like Country Music

133881428
President Barack Obama speaking during an event celebrating country music in the East Room of the White House in November.

Photo by MANDEL NGAN/AFP/Getty Images

To the delight of the chattering classes, President Obama released a campaign playlist on Spotify today. The 28 songs chosen by the president (or, more realistically, someone on his staff) cover a wide swath of the popular music landscape—though one genre seems conspicuously abundant, while another is notably absent.

The only musicians who appear more than once on Obama’s virtual mixtape are country duo Sugarland and former Hootie & the Blowfish frontman Darius Rucker, who, in his post-Blowfish days, digressed briefly into R&B before going deep into country’s terrain. Sugarland’s and Rucker’s tracks are among seven country songs on the playlist (the others are by Dierks Bentley, Montgomery Gentry, and Zac Brown Band).

Rucker and Bentley were among the musicians invited to the White House in November for a country music concert at which Obama said that he’d “gained an appreciation for just how much country music means to so many Americans”—but as far as Slate can tell, that appreciation doesn’t run particularly deep, nor does it seem to exist much beyond the campaign season. (Of the six artists listed in the “Favorite Music” section of Obama’s Facebook page, not one is a country musician.) The Atlantic’s David A. Graham analyzed Obama’s choice to devote a quarter of his campaign playlist to country music bluntly: “The president knows he needs to firm up his support among white working-class voters.”

Which might explain Obama’s complete omission of hip hop from his campaign playlist. Although one of his favorite musicians (again, per Facebook) is the Fugees, and although Obama has spoken of enjoying the music of Jay-Z, Nas, and Lil Wayne, he apparently didn’t think any of these rappers’ work fit for the campaign trail. Perhaps he’ll listen to their songs using Spotify’s “private listening” mode.

It seems likely that the sting of Fox’s dog-whistle headline from last summer—“Obama’s Hip-Hop BBQ Didn’t Create Jobs”—hasn’t yet worn off. It’s equally likely that those “white working-class voters” Obama is trying to court don’t overlap much with the demographic that rush to download Kanye West’s latest. Still, what a sad statement about America’s cultural and racial divide that Obama thinks the only safe political move is to pretend that an influential, diverse, American-born genre of pop music simply doesn’t exist.

 

Character Studies: Sterling Archer

archer

A still of Sterling Archer on Archer.

On tonight’s episode of FX’s animated espionage comedy Archer, the hero, ruggedly handsome Sterling Archer, leaps out of the elevator into his office, shouting, “Paging Dr. Boy! Dr. Birthday Boy!” He’s crestfallen when it turns out no one is waiting to throw him a surprise birthday party.

Here are some things Archer does that are less charming: He asks his elderly butler why he bothers going on living. He tells a fellow agent who’s just been shot to shut up so he can hear more about his birthday present. He tells a car he wants to have sex with it. He pulls machine guns on the yakuza. He blows up two police cars. And, when all is said and done, he weeps over the memory of a five-speed bike lost when he was eight years old.

That’s what I love about Archer in a nutshell: He has the wardrobe, sex life, and armaments of an adult superspy, but the soul (and impulse control) of a child.

Read More »