Who's the Boss?
How do I handle an employee who makes nasty comments when I can hear them?
Get "Dear Prudence" delivered to your inbox each week; click here to sign up. Please send your questions for publication to prudence@slate.com. (Questions may be edited.)
Dear Prudence,
After many years away from home, I decided to work for my family's manufacturing company. I am the boss's son, but work as hard as I can. My office is right next to the factory floor, with a Plexiglas window looking out to the floor. Recently, one of the floor managers was saying some pretty nasty things about me just outside that window, and I could very clearly hear just about everything. Now, I'm not upset about what he said, since most of it is nonsense, but I simply don't want to be subjected to hearing it! Is there some subtle way to tell him that I can hear everything he says when he's right outside my office? Is there a chance he realizes that I can hear and has chosen this location because of that, and, if so, should I confront him?
—The Boss's Son
Dear Son,
Even I know your idea about telling him to find a more private place to pass on scurrilous rumors about you is counterproductive. But for expert advice on management issues, I checked with Marty Kurtz of Kurtz Consulting Group in Randolph, N.J. He said it's not surprising that the return of the prodigal son as a new boss has stirred up questions and resentment. The floor manager's behavior is a direct challenge to your authority, and you must address it immediately. Call him in and calmly tell him you heard what he was saying about you, and that the two of you need to clarify a few things. One is that when one manager undermines another to the rest of the employees, it is damaging to everyone involved, and that's not how you run things or want to see them run. Another is that since it's clear he has concerns about your role and decisions, he has to bring such issues directly to you. Then give him the opportunity to respond. When you finish your discussion, reiterate that you hope he understands how you expect his concerns to be handled from now on, and that if the current situation continues, you will consider it to be a direct challenge to the management of the company.
—Prudie
Dear Prudence Video: Dirty Crossword
Dear Prudence,
I have been dating a wonderful guy for a little more than a year. He's a great guy and would be a great dad, but I don't have that head over heels in love feeling for him. During the first two months, I did have butterflies, but I don't know if that was just the excitement of a new relationship or the beginning of love. All that kind of faded when I realized he doesn't really fit in with my group of friends (who I am really close to—they are like family). But I do enjoy his company in every other way, just not around my friends. Here is the real problem: I want to have at least four kids. I'm approaching 30 and know I need to get started soon. However, I also have dreamed about finding the one—someone I'm head over heels for, my movie love. Do I choose to marry the great guy I'm with and start a family? Or hold out for true love? I'm afraid if I wait for love, I'll miss my opportunity to have a family and forever regret it. But I'm afraid if I settle for less than love, I'll always regret that.
—Contemplative
Dear Contemplative,
If I tell you it sounds like you have your true love, only you don't realize it and you should marry him and start your life together, would you think, "Hmm, she's right, that's good advice," or would you think, "Boy, she has no idea what she's talking about"? Only you know if you're the kind of person for whom a comfy "great guy" is enough. Here are a couple of questions to ask yourself as you make your decision: Have you ever experienced that kind of movie love you crave, or it is a fantasy of what love should feel like? How easy is it for you to meet men and establish new relationships? And I have a question to ask you: What's with your boyfriend and your friends not being able to get along with each other? You should explore whether your friends are actually an immature clique who resent your boyfriend because he represents moving to a new phase of life, or if their discomfort with him is a warning sign you have chosen to ignore.
—Prudie
Photograph of Prudie by David Plotz.


