How the New York Soda-Size Ruling Will Change the War On Fat

Science, technology, and life.
March 13 2013 5:30 AM

The Chronic Ills of Nannya

What’s the message of the New York soda-size ruling? Government can’t control lifestyle diseases the way it controls infectious epidemics.

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg on January 14, 2013.
New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg on January 14, 2013.

Photo by Patrick Semansky/AP

You can also listen to William Saletan read this piece.

William Saletan William Saletan

Will Saletan writes about politics, science, technology, and other stuff for Slate. He’s the author of Bearing Right.

Monday was a bad day for the food police. A judge in New York City ruled that the city’s board of health exceeded its authority last year when it limited sodas to 16 ounces. The judge gave several reasons, but here’s the one most likely to affect your life: Government can’t control lifestyle diseases the way it controls infectious epidemics.

Communicable diseases, such as smallpox or the flu, travel from person to person through microbes. Most chronic diseases, such as cancer, diabetes, and cardiovascular illness, don’t. They’re driven, as the World Health Organization explains, by “unhealthy lifestyles.” And this radically constrains the government’s ability and authority to control them.

Advertisement

The soda-size limit, which Mayor Michael Bloomberg calls a “portion cap,” never went through the city council. Bloomberg imposed it unilaterally last September through his board of health. The board cited Section 556 of the city charter, which authorizes the city health department to “regulate the food and drug supply” and “supervise the reporting and control of communicable and chronic diseases.” The board noted that “sugary drinks are a leading driver of the obesity epidemic and are associated with dangerous chronic diseases” such as diabetes and heart ailments.

This was an obvious stretch of the charter. When the city council inserted these clauses in 1977, few people saw obesity as a major chronic disease, and nobody saw portion control as part of ordinary food-supply regulation. And while the charter language did include chronic as well as communicable illness, it didn’t say that the department’s power to supervise disease control extended equally to both types.

The health department ignored these distinctions. A week before it approved the portion cap, it released a memo responding to complaints that controlling drink size “is not the government’s role.” The memo, signed by the department’s assistant commissioner for chronic disease prevention, noted that the board of health “has a successful track record of adopting rules that protect the health of New Yorkers, including bans on lead paint, tuberculosis control provisions, and requirements regarding calorie labeling and the elimination of trans fats from restaurants.”

Opponents picked apart these precedents. In an amicus brief filed with the court on Nov. 7, five dissenters on the city council pointed out that calorie counts are just information, that the trans fat ban was ratified by the council, and that lead paint, unlike soda, is inherently toxic. They added:

“Unlike obesity, tuberculosis is a dangerous, communicable disease, and the core function of health departments has long been to control such diseases and prevent extensive person-to-person spreading. … But obesity does not spread in this way. Rather, it develops based on a person’s personal characteristics and environment—including social, behavioral, and cultural factors. … Thus, [the health department’s] ‘control’ powers under the Charter with respect to [communicable] diseases … says nothing about the extent of [its] power to override individual preferences that might contribute to a non-communicable condition like obesity.”

Furthermore, the dissenters argued, the behavioral complexity of today’s chronic diseases meant that any agency fully authorized to control them would become an intrusive nightmare. They conceded that soda might contribute to chronic illness, but “so too does eating fatty foods, exercising too infrequently, or watching too much television.” Unfettered authority to stamp out these maladies, they warned, would empower the health department “to regulate such behaviors with no input from the Council.”

All of this was true. But it wasn’t the whole story. A day after the dissenters filed their brief, health advocates, led by Yale’s Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity, issued an amicus brief defending the portion cap. They argued that if health departments couldn’t tackle chronic disease, they couldn’t do their job:

“The most pressing public health problems today are obesity and obesity-related disease, such as diabetes and coronary heart disease. Long gone are the public health problems that historically affected large cities stemming from a lack of sanitation and high incidence of communicable disease. If health departments refused to act on this reality, they would be failing to meet their responsibilities to protect the public’s health.”

TODAY IN SLATE

Technocracy

Forget Oculus Rift

This $25 cardboard box turns your phone into an incredibly fun virtual reality experience.

Stop Panicking. America Is Now in Very Good Shape to Respond to the Ebola Crisis.

The 2014 Kansas City Royals Show the Value of Building a Mediocre Baseball Team

The GOP Won’t Win Any Black Votes With Its New “Willie Horton” Ad

Sleater-Kinney Was Once America’s Best Rock Band

Can it be again?

Politics

Smash and Grab

Will competitive Senate contests in Kansas and South Dakota lead to more late-breaking races in future elections?

I Am 25. I Don’t Work at Facebook. My Doctors Want Me to Freeze My Eggs.

These Companies in Japan Are More Than 1,000 Years Old

  News & Politics
The World
Oct. 21 2014 11:40 AM The U.S. Has Spent $7 Billion Fighting the War on Drugs in Afghanistan. It Hasn’t Worked. 
  Business
Business Insider
Oct. 21 2014 11:27 AM There Is Now a Real-life Hoverboard You Can Preorder for $10,000
  Life
Quora
Oct. 21 2014 11:37 AM What Was It Like to Work at the Original Napster?
  Double X
The XX Factor
Oct. 20 2014 6:17 PM I Am 25. I Don't Work at Facebook. My Doctors Want Me to Freeze My Eggs.
  Slate Plus
Tv Club
Oct. 20 2014 7:15 AM The Slate Doctor Who Podcast: Episode 9 A spoiler-filled discussion of "Flatline."
  Arts
Behold
Oct. 21 2014 12:05 PM Same-Sex Couples at Home With Themselves in 1980s America
  Technology
Technology
Oct. 21 2014 10:43 AM Social Networking Didn’t Start at Harvard It really began at a girls’ reform school.
  Health & Science
Climate Desk
Oct. 21 2014 11:53 AM Taking Research for Granted Texas Republican Lamar Smith continues his crusade against independence in science.
  Sports
Sports Nut
Oct. 20 2014 5:09 PM Keepaway, on Three. Ready—Break! On his record-breaking touchdown pass, Peyton Manning couldn’t even leave the celebration to chance.