Slate’s Culture Gabfest on the Canadian sci-fi series Orphan Black, Hateship Loveship, and the revised edition of Carl Wilson’s Let’s Talk About Love.

Is It OK to Hate Celine Dion?

Is It OK to Hate Celine Dion?

Slate's weekly roundtable.
May 7 2014 11:54 AM

The Culture Gabfest “Live from Montreal” Edition

Slate’s Culture Gabfest on Orphan Black, Hateship Loveship, and Carl Wilson’s Let’s Talk About Love.

The Culture Gabfest has moved! Find new episodes here.

Listen to Culture Gabfest No. 294 with Stephen Metcalf, Dana Stevens, and Julia Turner with the audio player below.

And join the lively conversation on the Culturefest Facebook page here:


The sponsor of this week’s show is Audible. Get a free audiobook from Audible’s collection of more than 150,000 titles and a subscription to a daily audio digest when you sign up for a 30-day free trial at This week’s pick for the Culture Gabfest Bucket List—the books you’ve got to read to be a smarter culture hound—is Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, read by either Susan Ericksen or Emma Messenger.

Sign up for Slate Plus to get ad-free podcasts, special bonus segments, discounted event tickets, a streamlined Slate reading experience, and more. Go to to learn more and join today. (You’ll also see a video from Steve, Dana, and Julia welcoming you to the program.)

Culturefest is on the radio! “Gabfest Radio” combines Slate’s Culture and Political Gabfests in one show—listen on Saturdays at 7 a.m. and Sundays at 6 p.m. on WNYC’s AM820.

And don’t forget you can find Culture Gabfest T-shirts for sale in the Slate store.


On this week’s episode, live from the Blue Metropolis Literary Festival in Montreal, the critics discuss the Canadian sci-fi series Orphan Black, which stars Tatiana Maslany as several identical women who are revealed to be clones. Maslany slips deftly into each role, but does the show’s writing stand up to her virtuosic performance? Next, the gabbers turn to Hateship Loveship, a film adaptation of Alice Munro’s short story “Hateship, Friendship, Courtship, Loveship, Marriage,” starring Kristen Wiig in a surprising dramatic turn. And finally, the Gabfest welcomes Slate music critic (and native Canadian) Carl Wilson to discuss the revised edition of his book Let’s Talk About Love, which reconsiders the role of “good taste” in pop music criticism. What’s a critic to do when kitsch is cool and cool is kitschy?

Links to some of the things we discussed this week follow:



Dana: The Angolan novelist Ondjaki, whose books Good Morning Comrades and Granma Nineteen and Soviet’s Secret she picked up at the Blue Met festival.

Julia: Norman McLaren, the grandfather of Canadian animation, whose mesmerizing short film “Horizontal Lines” is available on YouTube.

Carl: Owen Pallett, formerly known as Final Fantasy, whose new album “In Conflict” is his most emotionally frank.

Steve: Canadian political philosophers C.B. Macpherson and G.A. Cohen. In particular, Macpherson’s revelatory The Political Theory of Possessive Individualism: From Hobbes to Locke.  

Outro: “Montreal” by the Wingdale Community Singers

You can email us at

This podcast was produced by Andy Bowers and Ann Heppermann. Our intern is Anna Shechtman.

Follow us on Twitter. And please Like the Culture Gabfest on Facebook.

Stephen Metcalf is Slate’s critic at large. He is working on a book about the 1980s.

Dana Stevens is Slate’s movie critic.

Julia Turner, the former editor in chief of Slate, is a regular on Slate’s Culture Gabfest podcast.