Emily Yoffe, aka Dear Prudence, chats with readers weekly on Mondays here at Slate. An edited transcript of the chat is below. (Sign up here to get Dear Prudence delivered to your inbox each week. Read Prudie’s Slate columns here. Send questions to Prudence at firstname.lastname@example.org.)
Emily Yoffe: Good afternoon. I look forward to your questions—and your responses!
Q. My Hair, My Business: My best friend since middle school was recently diagnosed with lymphoma at only 28 years old. She starts chemo next week and has had an incredibly positive attitude. The one concern that she has expressed to me is that she doesn’t want to lose her hair. I told her that if does lose her hair I will be right there with her. Her younger sister and I have decided we want to shave our heads along with her so she doesn’t have to do it alone. My husband is completely fine with this, and friends and family that I’ve mentioned it to all say that they understand. My only concern is how to answer the questions that may come up from co-workers, acquaintances, etc. My hair is midway down my back so it’s not likely that it will go unnoticed. I don’t feel that it is anyone else’s business but I don’t want to be rude about it either.
A: I understand the loving impulse behind this gesture, but I advise putting down the razor. Seeing her own bald head reflected in yours will not help your friend get through her ordeal. She is going to need your support in more constructive ways. You can watch movies with her when she’s recovering from chemo. You can run errands for her. You can bring her chicken soup. You can rub her feet, you can cry with her, and then dry both your tears. If you shave your head you will inevitably have to deal with your own sadness at hacking off your beautiful hair and the questions from people about your health. Instead of getting unwanted and unproductive attention for yourself, save your energy to focus on your friend.
Q. Leftover Embryos: Now What?: I had twins two and a half years ago after a painful, protracted battle with infertility. I am happy with the size of my family, and so is my husband. The problem is that we have two frozen embryos. My husband does not really want more children, and, if these embryos did not exist, the thought wouldn’t even cross my mind. The problem is that I am emotionally attached to these embryos (and so is my husband, albeit to a lesser extent). I can’t bear the thought of destroying them or even donating them. The only option then seems to be using them to get pregnant. I know I would love another child, and my husband also says that he could do so. The problem is our hearts just aren’t in it in the way they should be. Is there something we are missing? I feel like I’ve explored all the options, and I can’t find any good solutions.
A: Please read your own letter and see how confused and conflicted your thinking is about having another child. First of all, you need to clarify whether your family is complete, and that decision should be made apart from the sense that a sibling is simply awaiting removal from the deep freeze. You’ve laid out your options: Another go-round at the fertility clinic; donation of the embryos; or destruction. However, you say you don’t want to pursue any of these. This website on surrogacy lays out thoroughly the ethical dilemmas parents like you face and makes the point that people become so overwhelmed by there being no good choice that they don’t make any decision. So they keep the embryos frozen year after year, paying a fee that could better be spent on the children they have. The surrogacy website notes that sometimes people just disappear—they stop paying the storage fee, thus defaulting the decision to the doctor, which isn’t fair. It certainly is justifiable that right now you’re not sure about whether to increase your family, so there’s nothing wrong with keeping your options open for the time being. But give yourself a deadline. Maybe by the time your twins are, say, 4 years old, you will make a pact that a decision, however difficult, must be made.
Q. Re: My hair, my business: I recently dealt with cancer. I already felt like a burden by needing to be taken care of. I would have felt even worse if someone drastically altered their physical appearance for me as well. A lot of times we’re expected to happily react to people’s demonstrations of support even if it makes us uncomfortable. I would really give this a second thought.
A: Thank you for this insight from someone who has been there. And I want to reassure those going through treatment that your friends and loved ones want to do things for you, the more specific the better. It’s not a burden, it’s a way of channeling concern into something useful.
Q. I Aborted Our Daughter: My husband and I were thrilled when we found out about my pregnancy, but that ended when our baby girl was diagnosed with Trisomy 18. Most babies with it die before birth, and only 1 in 10 who make it to birth get past their first birthday. We chose to abort her, which was the most painful experience of our lives. We simply told our families that it was a miscarriage. However, a few nosy relatives have started blabbing about how unusual and rare it is to miscarry in the mid-to-late second trimester. One even asked if it was “really” a miscarriage. Is there any benefit to being honest in these sorts of situations?
A: There’s only a benefit if you feel there are trusted people in your life with whom you would want to discuss this wrenching choice. But people who start nosing around about what “really” happened when you lost your baby immediately disqualify themselves from this circle. If the questions from them continue, you can say, “You’re right that late-term miscarriage is particularly painful. I appreciate your concern and your understanding that I don’t care to talk about it at all.”
Q. Co-Worker Lunch Clique: Soon after starting a new job I was invited to join a group of co-workers who eat lunch together every day in the cafeteria. At first I was happy to be included, but I quickly realized that this group hates the job, regularly takes more than our allotted break time, and may not be in the best graces with management. Furthermore, I don’t seem to have much in common with the group so most of lunch I just sit quietly studying my water bottle. What is the best way to extract myself from this clique?
A: Shades of the cafeteria scenes in Orange Is the New Black. Fortunately for you, you are not in a penal institution, even if your lunch mates act as if you are. I agree you need to break away from this group, but you want to do so without becoming a target of these malcontents. Start by mentioning to a couple of them that you’ve decided to use your lunch hour for exercise—then actually go out for a walk and grab your lunch outside. After a couple of weeks of this, you can mix it up by showing up in the cafeteria at a time that they generally are all leaving. Or take a book with you and say you’ve got to finish in time for your book club. Also feel free to sit with more pleasant colleagues. Sure, these whiners will notice you’re no longer part of their group, but maybe to your benefit management will too.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Most Terrifying Thing About Ebola
The disease threatens humanity by preying on humanity.
I Bought the Huge iPhone. I’m Already Thinking of Returning It.
Scotland Is Just the Beginning. Expect More Political Earthquakes in Europe.
Students Aren’t Going to College Football Games as Much Anymore
And schools are getting worried.
Two Damn Good, Very Different Movies About Soldiers Returning From War
Lifetime Didn’t Think the Steubenville Rape Case Was Dramatic Enough
So they added a little self-immolation.
Blacks Don’t Have a Corporal Punishment Problem
Americans do. But when blacks exhibit the same behaviors as others, it becomes part of a greater black pathology.