Adoption: I want my sister to keep her child.

Help! Girl Scouts Are Bullying My Kid.

Help! Girl Scouts Are Bullying My Kid.

Advice on manners and morals.
Oct. 20 2011 7:17 AM

Bye-Bye Baby

My sister is making a huge mistake by placing her child for adoption.

Emily Yoffe.
Emily Yoffe

Photograph by Teresa Castracane.

Get Dear Prudence delivered to your inbox each week; click here to sign up. Please send your questions for publication to (Questions may be edited.)

Got a burning question for Prudie? She'll be online at to chat with readers each Monday at 1 p.m. Submit your questions and comments here before or during the live discussion.


Dear Prudie,
My youngest sister, a junior in college, is pregnant. She is friendly with the baby's father but is not in a relationship with him, nor does she wish to have one. My sister and the baby's father decided to give their child up for adoption and quickly found a couple. I am having trouble accepting my sister's decision. I understand being 21 and finding yourself pregnant is not ideal, but our parents are well-off and are paying for her education. I said to her that as a mother myself, I did not understand how she could give her child away. I told her I would be happy to watch her baby while she is taking courses, since my kids are in school. I know our parents would help with the finances. I simply cannot understand why she is choosing adoption when she has support, both financial and otherwise. I think she is being a bit entitled. After all, she got herself into this mess, and it doesn't seem fair that she just gets to put the child up for adoption and resume her life. How can I impress upon her that she can, and should, take more responsibility for her actions?

—Willing To Help

Dear Willing,
Your sister is making one of the most difficult, and generous, decisions a young woman can make. After what must have been many agonizing nights of wondering how to proceed once she found herself pregnant, she realized that being a single college student meant she could not provide the life she would want for her child. So she decided that out of her pain would come something good, and a grateful couple will get to be parents. The real issue raised in your letter is what kind of person you are, since your attitude toward your sister is both contemptuous and baffling. Your opinion is irrelevant, so it doesn’t matter that you can’t accept your sister’s decision. You say that as a mother you cannot understand how your sister could “give her child away.” (I was once rightly rebuked by an adoptive mother who explained that children aren’t “given up” or “given away” but are “placed” for adoption—an important distinction that puts the act in better context.) Yet you view the pregnancy as a “mess,” one that your sister should not be able to just walk away from. Apparently you think she should be forced to raise her child as a fit punishment for what you see as her sense of entitlement. Perhaps the thought of handing her child over to you every day, and getting one of your superior little lectures, helped your sister make up her mind. No woman who places a child for adoption, no matter how right the decision, simply resumes her life unchanged. But her choice does leave me thinking that when the time comes and she is ready, she will be a wonderful mother.


Dear Prudence: Keep the Camera Off My Thighs!

Dear Prudence,
My 10-year-old daughter had a difficult time adjusting after our move to a new city last year. She was happy and well-liked at her previous school, but she suddenly became the victim of frequent taunting, even bullying, on the bus and playground. I had hoped that Girl Scouts would be a reprieve, but it was not. Most of the troop members attend her school, and on a field trip I saw them ostracize my daughter with eye-rolling, turning their backs, and making snide comments to her. My daughter told me the worst of them all was the troop leader's child. But she wanted to stay in the troop because her best friend was in it. I didn’t talk with the leaders because my daughter was afraid it would make things worse for her. Recently, two of the leaders asked to meet with me and informed me that my daughter had made an unkind comment to one of their daughters, and suggested my daughter leave the troop. I asked my daughter about this, and she said the girls in the troop frequently told her they didn’t like her, so she said it back. I went to the mothers and said there were issues on both sides. They said my daughter was being untruthful. I then told the leader about the taunting and humiliation my daughter has endured from her child and suggested she was unfit to be a leader. I subsequently sent an apology, but my husband feels the atmosphere has been poisoned, and we have no choice but to pull my daughter out of the troop. I'm not sure what to do.

—Confused and Still Angry

Dear Angry,
After that last conversation with the troop leaders, I admire you for not trying to choke them with a box of Thin Mints. It’s understandable you turned the tables on that overgrown mean girl, and you deserve a merit badge for apologizing to her. Your daughter may want to be with her best friend, but I agree with your husband that this poisonous little troop is no place for your little girl. Instead, find some alternative activity that would allow her to be with kids who come from many other schools—look into sports, theater, or art classes. Arrange get-togethers for your daughter with classmates and neighborhood kids who aren’t part of this noxious clique. As for stopping the taunting at school, I talked to Slate's expert on bullying, Emily Bazelon, who said you should meet with administrators about what’s happening and be as specific and nonconfrontational as you can. Given recent changes in the law in some states and the generally charged nature of the word bullying, she suggests caution about using that term, especially if your daughter has (understandably) responded in kind to the mean things said to her. But there needs to be a plan to get your daughter help. Sometimes kids who are being tormented at recess or in the cafeteria can spend that time elsewhere, assisting a teacher, for example. And if the bus ride is giving your daughter ulcers, it might be good to temporarily get her to school another way if possible. If you feel there’s a power imbalance between your daughter and the other girls, Bazelon warns against “peer mediation.” In this situation, victims and bullies face each other, and all too often the mean ones say during the session what the adults want to hear, and then when the grown-ups go away, they get their revenge. For insight into what your daughter is going through, look at the work of Rachel Simmons, author of Odd Girl Out. I hope that your stepping up means soon your daughter will be coming home and telling you today was a good day at school.


Dear Prudence,
My boss is a really good dentist, does excellent work, can be charming, and is ethical. Unfortunately, sometimes he goes through bouts of really insane behavior. He will threaten to blow his brains out while sweating profusely. He has panic attacks in which his face becomes red and he breathes hard. All of this is in front of patients. He becomes paranoid and tells patients that his staff is stealing from him, or he humiliates the staff by telling the patients that we are incompetent. He did once apologize to us for losing control, but usually he just tries to minimize how frightening his behavior was. What should I do?

—Dental Madness