Slate Magazine
Home dialogues
Go to Ask.com
SIDEBAR

Return to Article

Slate Contents

Equally, where Alex saw droves of evolutionary psychologists, I counted only Steve Pinker. Audible to me, if not to Alex, was the roar made by the grinding teeth of those evolutionists who disagree with or even despise evolutionary psychology, as they are casually labeled evolutionary psychologists. It is true that some journalists have mistakenly used "evolutionary psychology" to mean anyone who has an opinion about the relationship between human evolution and behavior, but this would make Stephen Jay Gould and Richard Lewontin leading evolutionary psychologists, a description I will relish reading someday if this journalistic usage spreads. Of course, the fact that MacDonald disagrees with evolutionary psychology's claims and principles does not necessarily make him wrong. It just makes him not an evolutionary psychologist.