HOME / technology: The future and what to do about it.

Et tu, Mario?Murder, looting, pizza theft, and other hazards of cooperative video-gaming.

By Jamin Brophy-WarrenPosted Friday, Nov. 13, 2009, at 4:51 PM ET

New Super Mario Bros. Wii This past year, during a brave attempt to weather the sweaty show floor of the video-game industry's annual E3 conference, I stopped by the enormous display dedicated to Nintendo. Unlike many publishers that show videos of their upcoming titles but won't let the public play them, Nintendo had bushels of flat-screen televisions pumping its biggest game of the year, the New Super Mario Bros. Wii. The most marketable feature of this new version of the franchise is the addition of four-player cooperative play, meaning I had the chance to play with three random strangers. I stepped up to the booth, grabbed a controller, and immediately had flashbacks to my youth—the many parts of my childhood, at least, when I'd start crying because of various Nintendo crimes perpetrated by my younger brother.

RSS

The ostensible object of New Super Mario Bros. is to advance through each level as a cohesive unit. The plot: Mario, Luigi, and a pair of "mushroom people" work together in yet another attempt to rescue the hapless princess from the clutches of Bowser's minions. The fellow next to me, however, felt no inklings of team spirit and proceeded to stomp on my head, steal my power-ups, and generally act like a complete "greedy Gus," as my mom would say. Immediately infantilized, I was transported back to the living room of my childhood, where my brother used to torment me by driving my on-screen character to some unseemly demise, insisting that he was "just playing the game his way." I left the Nintendo booth dismayed and frustrated and had the overwhelming desire to call my mother and gripe.

What is it about games that bring out the worst human behaviors? I'm sure the guy next to me was a wonderful human being, a delightful co-worker, and a caring husband and father. But in this game, he was the Poseidon to my Odysseus—yes, it felt that epic—an enemy bent on ensuring that I would never reach the promised land. As long as you don't take it too personally, cooperative play reveals what makes video games such a special medium. Being granted the opportunity to be friends or adversaries, games allow us to act out the worst of human pathologies and encourage behaviors that would get us yelled at, arrested, or killed in the real world.

Multiplayer video games operate along two dimensions. There are fighting games like the Tekken and Street Fighter franchises that give players a single option: defeat each other in glorious battle or turn off the console and bake cookies together. On the other end are games like the popular Facebook application FarmVille, in which players must help each other by fertilizing one another's crops and exchanging gifts. (Watch out for lead-generation scams, though!) Most cooperative games lie in a vast middle ground, however, a no man's land between altruism and gaming Darwinism that offers up a host of ways to misbehave.

My brother, whom I love dearly, is an exemplar of in-game selfishness. There was a particular sequence in the old Nintendo game Contra that involved jumping up the side of a waterfall. If one player jumps too quickly, the other gets left behind and falls to his demise. My little brother did this almost every single time, deliberately leaving my hapless soldier to die. He would cackle and cheer until I unplugged his controller or broke into tears. (My composure in the face of adversity has since improved.)

My brother's waterfall antics were a predecessor to a common issue in first-person shooter games: friendly fire. Greedy players often disregard the lives of others—stealing weapons that a fellow teammate was carrying, for instance—in a bid to improve their own statistics. "Splash damage" is a common problem with weapons like rocket launchers that destroy everything in a certain radius, including unlucky teammates. The company Infinity Ward, which released Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 to record sales this week, released a fake public-service announcement in which Phillies pitcher Cole Hamels discusses the dangers of throwing grenades in multiplayer mode. (The phony PSA has since been pulled on account of its childish homophobia; the interest group that Hamels represents is called "Fight Against Grenade Spam.")

Page: 1 | 2 SINGLE PAGE

E-MAIL

RECOMMEND... Get Slate RSS Feeds

Formerly an arts and entertainment reporter for the Wall Street Journal, Jamin Brophy-Warren is a freelance writer living in New Haven, Conn. You can e-mail him at and follow him on Twitter.

COMMENTS

It is this tendency to overcompete that drove me away from online play. The Internet brings out the worst traits in people by removing the barriers that force them to act civilly. Certain people just don't seem to realize that it's just a game and as such play as if every move was life and death - leaving no room for other's mistakes, less than perfect obedience, and otherwise obsessing over something as trivial as a game. It's just a minority too, but due to their drive for success, their thirst for dominance they immediately force everyone else to adopt their play style in order to have even a shred of hope of competing. Pretty soon people begin to forget that in the real world people who act like this are called assholes and treated as such. Personally I don't think it's because they don't have a life in the real world, but rather they live their life in two states - on/off. That's about as shallow as you can get.

I couldn't keep up after a while. I had to stop and say "hey guys I have a job to hold down - sorry I can't play 10 hours a day 7 days a week."

-- Eaigenvector
(To reply, click here)

People can be divided in 3 categories...

1. Those who will behave decent even in the absence af law (constructive society leaders).

2. Those who will follow the law out of fear of reprisals from leaders (society followers - majority) but otherwise are erratic / random and may behave badly if no punishment present.

3. Those who behave badly no matter what (destructive society leaders or criminals).

Video games are sort of like Wild Wild West - you can simply see who has a nature of a sheriff, a bandit, or a John the Farmer.

-- paxterminus
(To reply, click here)

My favorite game series, the Battlefield series, does add punishments for jerks and rewards for team players. Since the beginning, friendly fire was an option that could be turned on and off. Later, particularly in BF2, rewards were given for healing and resupplying team mates. Fraging friendlies or team killing just to get a jet or weapons pack draws negative points and on some servers, can get you kicked off quite quickly. It's not perfect and there are some loopholes but it's possible to develop a game that encourages team playing. In Battlefield, the best teams are ones that work together. Most first person team shooter games are like this.

Your conversation with Wii's creator sounds like it's the issue. He's use to friendly games where jerks don't troll looking to spoil others fun. Team play incentives can be put in the game if the developers want to work at it.

-- coldcut
(To reply, click here)

What did you think of this article?

Join The Fray: Our Reader Discussion Forum

POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES