HOME / tv club: Talking television.

Mad Men, Season 3

Week 9: Don's Strange Response to "I Have a Dream."

Posted Monday, Oct. 12, 2009, at 10:56 AM ET

I couldn't agree more about these two affairs, Julia. I was really hoping you were right when you predicted last week that we'd seen the last of Henry Francis. And I didn't think it possible, but Miss Farrell makes me miss Joy from Season 2. I preferred her straightforward sensuality and carefully designed topless swimsuits to Miss Farrell's cocky idealism and Bowdoin T-shirt. "You think they can understand it?" Don asks Miss Farrell when she proclaims she's going to play the "I Have a Dream" speech to her class. "I think they already know it," she replies. I'm pretty sure I've rolled my eyes every time this woman has been on-screen this season.

I confess that this whole episode left me cold, even the action set at Sterling Cooper. I complained a few weeks ago that it'd been too long since we'd seen anyone come up with an ad campaign. Like you, Julia, I enjoyed the scene in which Don grumpily rejects his underlings' ideas. (His dismissal of Kurt was especially memorable: "Now that I can finally understand you, I am less impressed with what you have to say.") Yet the episode jumped too quickly from those bad ideas to the final campaign, with no sense of how Don got there or even whose idea it was. And while it was refreshing to see a client unmoved by the Don Draper hard sell, Connie's reason for not liking the campaign was so loopy, it had the effect of making me side with Don.

I suppose that Connie's reaction to the campaign could have been what drove Don into Miss Farrell's arms, as you suggested, Julia. (Certainly, in a very literal sense, Connie made that assignation possible by giving Don an excuse to leave the house in the wee small hours.) But it was Connie who was really pushing the "you're like a son" thing. I've had the sense that Don wants to please Connie because he is a big client—one that Don reeled in on his own—and because he admires Hilton's trajectory from obscurity to wealth and power. Over that Prohibition-era hooch, Connie also calls Don his "angel" and calls himself King Midas. Is Don so desperate for a father figure that he'd latch on to such ramblings? Maybe. But I couldn't tell whether his response to Connie's rejection of the campaign was that of a spurned son or just a spurned creative who believes in his work. Or whether, like me, Don's getting a little tired of Connie's eccentric self-made-man routine.

As for Sal, I, too, was holding out hope that Don would protect him as he did Peggy last season. I found Don's response to Sal's description of the incident a little puzzling. At first, Don seems not to believe that Sal repulsed Lee Garner Jr.'s advances—"you sure you want to do that?" he asks when Sal swears on his mother that nothing happened. But then Don quickly changes his tune, insinuating that Sal should have done whatever was necessary to please the client, particularly one that's big enough to turn Sterling Cooper's lights out. Couldn't Don have let Sal lie low for a while, as Sal suggests? Was Lee Garner Jr. really going to demand to see Sal's pink slip? I understand that big clients get to be capricious. But how would Lee Garner Jr. explain his vendetta against Sal to Roger, or, for that matter, to Lee Garner Sr.? Maybe Don fired Sal simply because it terrifies him to contemplate a scenario in which a closely held secret comes between a man and his career.

Returning to the "I Have a Dream" speech, I wonder if you guys were also surprised at Don's reaction to it. He tries to turn it off when it comes on the radio, and when Miss Farrell makes him listen, he seems at best uninterested and at worst disgusted by the clip. I wouldn't have expected Roger Sterling to admire King's address, but I would have guessed that Don might recognize its eloquence and the import of the moment. In the past, we've witnessed Don's efforts to keep up with the times—smoking marijuana with his Village girlfriend in Season 1, reading Frank O'Hara in Season 2—and he seems more enlightened about race than some of his colleagues. As we've discussed previously, he chatted up a black waiter in the pilot, and this season he expressed revulsion at Roger's blackface routine. At the very least, as a man who uses words to sell ideas for a living, I was surprised Don didn't seem to recognize King's gift for delivering his message.

Yet another mention of Dallas this week. The way things are going, I'm now half-expecting Don to be picnicking on the grassy knoll come the season finale.

I really want a pencil case to put in my loose leaf,
John

Week 9: Don's Strange Response to "I Have a Dream."

Posted Monday, Oct. 12, 2009, at 10:56 AM ET
Print This ArticlePRINTEmail to a FriendE-MAILShare This ArticleRECOMMEND...Get Slate RSS FeedsRSS
Patrick Radden Keefe is the author of The Snakehead: An Epic Tale of the Chinatown Underworld and the American Dream, which has just been published. John Swansburg is Slate's culture editor. You can e-mail him at and follow him at www.twitter.com/swansburg. Julia Turner is Slate's deputy editor. You can e-mail her at or follow her on Twitter at http://twitter.com/juliaturner.
Stills from Mad Men © 2009 American Movie Classics Company LLC. All rights reserved. Stills in entries 65-70 by Carin Baer.
COMMENTS

Series creator Matthew Weiner has stated he leaves nothing for future seasons and puts everything out there each season, like its the last, and this episode could almost double as a series finale. I think when Mad Men eventually ends its run, there will be discussion whether this episode was the proper series finale and should have called it quits right here, or will Weiner have new and interesting places to take us in season 4?

-- guyroy
(To reply,
click here)

"And the way that they saw themselves is gone." Julia, I think this pretty clearly refers to Peggy having her child and giving it away. Until Peggy told Pete about the baby, Don was only person on the show outside of her family and priest that knew her secret. Don was the one that visited Peggy in the hospital after she gave birth and had been out of work for a while.

-- BumblebeeMan
(To reply,
click here)

Who's in charge, Betty or Henry? Something that surprised me was the amount of involvement Henry had in Betty's divorce advice. Does it ring true for the period that Henry went to the lawyer with Betty and apparently also knew the lawyer and may have selected the lawyer for Betty? And, when Betty told Don that she would be consulting with a divorce attorney and Don should too, was she simply parroting Henry's words?

Certainly since Henry's divorced he knows the routine and I can understand him giving Betty the benefit of his experience. Last episode Henry was willing to give Betty the time she needed and he would wait. Now, things are fast-tracked to Reno. I'm sure that it's been hard for Betty to continue to live in the same house with Don who continues to deny Betty's feelings. But, seeing Betty sitting in the lawyer's office on the sofa with Henry, reminded me of Betty sitting on the sofa with Glen last season. Then, when Don confronts Betty about Henry, they seem to be having their first real fight.

Anyway, I wonder if Betty/Henry are the 'lasting love' mentioned in the Roy Orbison song at the end.

-- lkd711
(To reply,
click here)

I think season 4 will include a serious health issue for Don-perhaps lung cancer. Note the cough at the beginning of the last episode. Also the brief scene when Sterling's dog food heiress old flame states that her first husband died of lung cancer, there is a brief cut to Don lighting up another. Thoughts while I write an order for Don to get a screening cat scan.

-- ldbmd
(To reply,
click here)

What did you think of this article?
Join The Fray: Our Reader Discussion Forum
POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES
TODAY'S PICTURES
TODAY'S CARTOONS
TODAY'S DOONESBURY
TODAY'S VIDEO
The beauty parlor.16/091209_TP.jpg
Cartoonists' take on Wall Street.44/091209_TC.jpg
Rogue rules.87/091209_TD.jpg