Will the Transgender Dad Be a Father?What goes on the birth certificate.
Posted Friday, June 13, 2008, at 5:32 PM ET
As people across the country fête their fathers this weekend, a transgender man in Oregon will enter the final weeks of his first successful pregnancy. Thomas Beatie, who's male according to state law but who retains his female reproductive organs, underwent artificial insemination because his wife was unable to bear children. Will the baby's birth certificate register Beatie as the father or the mother?
PRINT
DISCUSS
E-MAIL
RSS
RECOMMEND...
Facebook
MySpace
Mixx
Digg
Reddit
del.icio.us
Furl
Ma.gnolia
Sphere
StumbleUponThe mother, but it can subsequently be changed. Oregon statutes define live birth to include "expulsion or extraction [of the living child] from its mother," and the state's Department of Human Services interprets this clause and others to mean that a birth certificate must declare the childbearer (in this case, Beatie) to be the mother. It doesn't need to be his permanent status, though. As soon as the initial paperwork is squared away at the hospital, Beatie and his wife are free to petition for a court order to have a new birth certificate issued, this time listing Beatie as the father and his wife as the mother.
This switcheroo is a well-established legal procedure, even though Beatie's circumstances have no clear precedent in Oregon law. It's commonly used in cases of surrogacy, when a "gestational carrier" is pregnant with the embryo of people who will claim parentage at birth. A preliminary birth certificate names the childbearer as mother; another follows with the destined parents replacing her. Beatie would approach this process as if he were his own surrogate. He'd effectively change his status from birth mother to destined father and allow his wife to claim motherhood. Lesbian couples in Oregon sometimes use a similar formality: A biological mother can adopt her own child with her lesbian partner, making the two women equal parents (though one may end up in the "father" slot of the birth certificate).
Maneuvers like that may soon be unnecessary; there's a growing trend to award same-sex couples equal parentage from the start, even when one woman has no biological relationship to the child. And Beatie may have other options, anyway. Conceivably, he could avoid even a temporary "mother" status by invoking a 2007 state amendment (PDF) that outlaws discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, defined to include "gender identity, regardless of whether the individual's gender identity, appearance, expression or behavior differs from that traditionally associated with the individual's sex at birth." To call Beatie a mother, a lawyer might argue, would be to treat him as something other than a man—an illegal discrimination against his current sexual orientation.
Either way, Beatie's change to the original birth certificate would be largely symbolic: There are few, if any, circumstances under which his designation as mother versus father would have broader legal effects. Even if he and his wife were to split, for instance, decisions about parenting (the technical term for custody) wouldn't take his paternity into account. These rulings are forbidden to show gender preference in Oregon—and the law tends to favor shared-parenting arrangements, anyway. What's relevant to such decisions is whether Beatie is his child's parent, and no one disagrees that he is.
Got a question about today's news? Ask the Explainer.
Explainer thanks Leslie Harris at the University of Oregon School of Law, Mara Keisling at the National Center for Transgender Equality, Shannon Price Minter at the National Center for Lesbian Rights, and Jennifer Woodward at the Oregon Department of Human Services.
Is Hasan a Terrorist? And Other Great Stories From Slate This Week.
How Sarah Palin Is Dividing the Republican Party
Can We Apply the Lessons of Y2K to Swine Flu?
They Made a Movie About the Wrong Aviatrix
Jamie Foxx's New Single Is Extremely Lewd
The Week's Best Editorial Cartoons
Remarks from the Fray:
No matter what surgery, hormones and dress you apply to a woman, she remains a woman. This is not a man having a baby. This is a woman with mental problems having a baby. If someone believes they are Napoleon, we dont' salute them. That doesn't mean we need to arrest them or deny them civil rights, but Joe from Accounting is not the Little Emperor, no matter what his brain tells him.
The fact that there is a cottage industry of people willing to humor such people does not change the fact - ovaries = female. Biological curiousities like XYY chromosome carriers and anatomical hermaphrodites don't blur the line either. This case is very simple - a woman who society is allowing to use a male pronoun on legal documants is pregnant. It takes Red Queen-thinking to believe anything else.
--JonFrum
(To reply, click here.)
(6/13)