Buzzing Over The WireJeffrey Goldberg and David Plotz take readers' questions about HBO's hit urban drama.
Posted Thursday, March 6, 2008, at 4:59 PM ET
PRINT
DISCUSS
E-MAIL
RSS
RECOMMEND...
Facebook
MySpace
Mixx
Digg
Reddit
del.icio.us
Furl
Ma.gnolia
Sphere
StumbleUpon_______________________
The courthouse snitch: Has to be Rhonda.
Jeffrey Goldberg: Such a cynic, you.
_______________________
Southeast Washington: Let's not forget the best potential byproduct of the wire—"Hampsterdam." For all the nonsense, I think that could work in the U.S.
Jeffrey Goldberg: It didn't work so well on The Wire, though, if you'll recall. To the show's credit—and it is a show that is opposed to the Drug War—Hamsterdam wasn't prettified. It was a nasty place which trapped innocent people in its despair and perversity.
_______________________
Albany, N.Y.: The two of you have spent a lot of time questioning the "realism" of the Baltimore Sun plot. Why is perfect adherence to real life such an important factor in your enjoyment of the show? Isn't it possible that other institutions have been portrayed with just as much deviation from real life and you just did not notice? More importantly, is documentary-style realism the true goal of a series that is compared to Greek mythology, or is the verisimilitude just a well-executed artistic device?
David Plotz: I agree with that beef. I dislike the newspaper portrayal, but I am willing to grant Simon liberty to play around. I doubt his police department or drug gang is perfectly accurate either. The problem with the newspaper is less that it's an inaccurate portrait of a paper than that the characters are not very compelling. They are psychologically narrower than the characters in the others seasons/plots
_______________________
Vancouver, Canada: Am I the only one who thinks McNulty's deception is going to be covered up? Maybe he takes a fall inside the police department by being forced to resign (or sent back to the marine unit/evidence locker), but is Carcetti (or Rawls for that matter) really going to let the big drug bust go up in smoke? That would end his chances for Annapolis in a pinch. The only wild card is Levy, but Lester appears to be cooking something up on that end...
Jeffrey Goldberg: You sound like a very clever person.
_______________________
Washington Post: Have you read the blog "Stuff White People Like"? It fits you two exactly, from knowing what's good for poor people to not watching TV.
David Plotz: I love that Web site! Multilingual children! Pretending to like soccer!
_______________________
New York: Why didn't you tell me about The Wire? I just started watching it two weeks ago and am now finished with Season 3. I am now Bubbles, begging my neighbor for a Season 4 fix. Will not read the chat for fear of learning. Stupid HBO put Omar RIP on the Web site, and that was beat.
Jeffrey Goldberg: Yes, that was indeed beat.
_______________________
Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: Jeffrey, you clearly came into this TV Club with an axe to grind against David Simon and his newspaper subplot. Are you normally this unobjective in your writing, or was it just because this was "only a TV show"? Regardless, I found it very amateurish, and it certainly doesn't make me want to read anything else you've written.
Jeffrey Goldberg: Axe to grind? I've called him a genius.
Some axe.
_______________________
David Plotz: Thanks for all the great questions, and have a wonderful Sunday night!
What the Washington Post Gets Wrong About Kids and Heroin
Should You Give to International Charities or Local Ones?
The Catastrophes That Befall Troy Patterson as He Tries To Cook Along With Gordon Ramsay
Can Schools Punish Bullies for Making Mean YouTube Videos?
Can Video Games Make You Do Things You Don't Want To Do?
The Scottish Masturbation Club You'll Wish You Never Heard Of
