Deep Eco-MetalDelve far enough into heavy metal, and you'll find environmentalists.
Posted Tuesday, Nov. 13, 2007, at 1:44 PM ET
PRINT
DISCUSS
E-MAIL
RSS
RECOMMEND...
Facebook
MySpace
Mixx
Digg
Reddit
del.icio.us
Furl
Ma.gnolia
Sphere
StumbleUponSo, how did three guys from Olympia, Wash., neo-hippies and veterans of the DIY punk scene, come to emulate this deeply European music, and to make it so thoroughly their own? On the surface, the Wolves are not your typical black-metal band. Besides being American—black-metal bands in the United States are few and far between—they don't go in for corpse-paint or silly pseudonyms. Most importantly, their music is unusually textured and rich. On the their recent album Two Hunters (Southern Lord), melodies slash through a shoe-gazing haze of guitars, analog synths, and shimmering cymbals. Genres are woven together, with folk, ambient, goth, and environmental samples rising and falling through the material like tides. For the first half of "Cleansing," which opens with the crackling of a fire, guest singer Jessica Kinney provides a clean and keening lament over a steady tribal beat. Most black-metal bands sound cornball when they go softy like this, but the music here conjures the mournful exotica of the Goth crossover band Dead Can Dance.
You can't understand the lyrics, of course, and the band, in a typical black-metal move, does not print them. However, the aural sleuths at the Encyclopaedia Metallum, which tracks more than 50,000 metal bands, do offer some convincing transcriptions. These suggest that Two Hunters is about an apocalyptic struggle. On one side, there's a cruel mounted priest-king, whose steed beats the earth to "lifeless chaos" with his 24-7 galloping. On the other, there's a tribe of earth folk who flee into the forest, dance in the dark of night, and prepare for a final conflagration and a cleansing rain. The album closes with the 18-minute (!) swan song "I Will Lay Down My Bones Among the Rocks and Roots." While not abandoning the tragic mode, the song's shiny timbres and a yearning, hopeful chord progression sound the first glimmerings of a new dawn, when "the sun god is born anew."
The contours of this myth echo what my chat with the band after the Santa Cruz show confirmed: Wolves in the Throne Room are hard-core tree-huggers, with a Manichaean view of the environmental crisis and a pagan faith in the transformative powers of nature. I mostly talked to Aaron, an articulate and intelligent fellow wearing a green Tyrolean hat. After honing his politics in the Pacific Northwest's DIY punk scene, Aaron moved to D.C. to fight the good fight as a secular lefty. It didn't work out, and he moved back to Olympia, where a surprising series of spiritual experiences he hasn't really talked about made him a clear-eyed seeker of earth wisdom. With his brother and their respective partners, he now lives on 10 acres of land near Evergreen State College, where his posse is painstakingly crafting a sustainable life off the grid. And finding time to play hard-core, shamanic eco-metal.
"The intersection of dark, spiritual music and radical ecology is quite natural," explains Aaron, who has not given up on the DIY punk scene's penchant for packaging radical political platforms with music. In interviews, he'll make favorable mention of the Earth Liberation Front—some of whose monkey-wrenching adherents have been branded as "terrorists." He also expresses cautious admiration for Finland's merciless eco-philosopher Pentti Linkola, who argues that the best way out of the environmental crisis lies in a swift, lethal, and authoritarian process of de-industrialization.
This is disturbing stuff, and it's supposed to be. I mean, aren't you a bit disturbed? Lots of people who open their souls to today's seemingly relentless assault on wild creatures and wild places find themselves gripped by bitterness, melancholy, and misanthropy. For the Wolves, black metal just makes sense; it's melodramatic Satanism transformed into an angry lament for human folly. But the band doesn't just mourn. It also aims its epic melodies toward the old Romantic sublime, drawing the listener into the dream of a vital and resurgent earth. Which is why, as the long last stretch of blistering riffs echoed through the Santa Cruz woods that night, the crowd started headbanging like dervishes, discovering in the harsh hyperspeed beats a deeper, more archaic pulse.
The John Cassavetes Movie That Changed American Cinema Forever
Am I Wasting My Money if I Give to a Needy Family at Christmas?
Troy Patterson: What I Love About Glee
Hurray! We Won the War on Spam.
Bill Simmons' The Book of Basketball Is a Crude, Fantastic Mess
Thanks, FDA, but We Don't Need Your Protection From Raw Oysters
Remarks from the Fray:
Wolves in the Throne Room are not one of the black metal bands deserving of much in the way of recognition. They're not doing anything new or particularly outstanding. Musically, they remain almost entirely derivative of DarkThrone and Burzum, probably the two most widely imitated bands in the genre (though lacking the instinct for dramatic composition that made those earlier acts so powerful). The 'folk, goth, ambient and environmental samples' that Davis seems to think are unique have been genre staples at least since the early 1990s.
Likewise, their environmental views are hardly unique in a scene noted for its embrace of a heathen revivalism, feral naturalism, a Romantic idealism and political fascism. DarkThrone's Fenriz, Burzum's Varg Vikernes, most of the members of Emperor and Ildjarn/Sort Vokter have been on the record as supporters of radical positions on ecological issues. Fellow Pacific Northwesterners Windham Hell, who released a series of wildly creative black metal albums in the mid and late 1990s took a similar stance.
Where Wolves in the Throne Room differ is not in outlook, but in elevating environmental consciousness to the status of a record-selling gimmick. What's really new here isn't the music or the ideas, but how the music and ideas are packaged for marketing purposes. Southern Lord's staff has deep connections with the indie scene, and much of the success of the label's marketing arm has been based on making use of those connections to market their bands to indie fans. Southern Lord also learned a great deal from the marketing tactics that worked for indie bands, so you get both the sort of viral publicity stunts designed to make every appearance an EVENT! as well as the more mundane tactic of getting favorable write-ups from old pals in strategically chosen hipster outlets (this article, for instance).
The result has been a lot of interest in some fairly uninteresting bands, but the interest is coming largely from quarters that have no historical interest, connection to or understanding of the genre. It's an excellent model for short term profit, but not much of a model for sustained artistic relevance. Or, for that mater, any artistic relevance at all.
--Planetary Eulogy
(To reply, click here.)
What really unnerves me about this article is the mention of the philosophies that we as a species should undo our industrialization and return to a primitive, pagan nature-worshipping state. What I wish I could ask someone who represents this mindset and mentality is:
1. Why do you choose to ignore the goods that have come with industrialization? Longer lives, better health, and a deeper scientific understanding of the universe?
2. Why would you willingly doom the entire human race to eventual extinction? By undoing industrialization, not only do all the advances in medicine and science that allowed humans to expand and extend their lives get removed, but any hope of eventually expanding off Earth and colonizing the stars are gone. We don't currently know if there's life on other planets, and in the unlikely event that this planet is it in all of the universe, how could any eco-philosopher willingly deny Life itself the ability to expand into new and unknown ecosystems in the hopes of avoiding the eventual planetary death that will kill the earth? Currently, Humanity in all its folly and glory is the only means that Life has to get off the planet and expand, and even survive in the long term.
To me the statements and beliefs attributed to the eco-philosophers and the black-metal bands in this article are not pro-environment. To me, this is the manifestation of a desperate desire for absolute destruction based out of self-hatred and despair, cloaking itself in an environmentalist cause to give itself validity in today's world.
--Xaedalus
(To reply, click here.)
(11/17)