Slate's Bizbox
politics: Who's winning, who's losing, and why.

Fred's Mixed First DayAfter a sluggish start, the actor adapts.

By John Dickerson
Posted Thursday, Sept. 6, 2007, at 10:18 PM ET
Fred Thompson. Click image to expand.

Fred Thompson's first day on the stump had all the signs of a big campaign. Two gold and blue buses wrapped with stars and swishes sat outside the Polk County convention center in Iowa. On the side of each was a giant picture of the candidate and his slogan: "United by Our Core Beliefs." Handmade signs lined the walls of the convention center's Room 205, where Thompson was scheduled to hold his first event. They suggested swarms of regular folk yearning to show their love. (They'd really been made by a handful of volunteers the night before.) At two tables, stacks of campaign buttons were for sale. A former Miss Iowa sang the national anthem. There was a picture of the candidate with Ronald Reagan.

The press turned out in force. We filled half the room, facing a gigantic structure with pillars and molding that looked like the Doric facade of a downtown bank in a midsized city. Housed between the pillars and faux sandstone were three enormous flat screens, two for video and one with a repeating pattern of the campaign buzzwords Security. Unity. Prosperity. (Yes, a slogan and buzzwords.)

The only thing missing was the crowd. About 200 Iowans showed up to see Thompson. His aides insisted that the number was 400, but they might have been counting the press. A crowd of 200 isn't embarrassing on a Thursday afternoon in Des Moines, but it isn't great. It's really not great if you're the savior of the Republican Party. There's not a lot of historical data on support for well-known actors who enter the campaign as the late great hope of a depressed party, but one might have expected to see lines out the door, a shortage of sign-up sheets, a fire marshal warning about overcrowding. The Thompson event had none of these things.

Before the senator arrived, a local radio host ran through Thompson's résumé. This drew no strong applause. A three-minute campaign video cycled through black and white pictures. They told the story of Thompson's biography but started with a picture of Obama, Edwards, and Clinton and text that read "The Hunt for Red November." (Geddit?)

Thompson's speech was fine, I suppose, but at times it seemed rambling and forced. It included all the standard appeals you would expect a politician to offer a Republican audience—support for local control, lower taxes, and judges who will protect the Constitution. Thompson made no effort to distinguish himself from the other candidates. At applause-line moments, his staffers clapped loudly and whooped, an age-old tactic that succeeded in prompting clapping from the audience.

Afterward, a senior Thompson aide argued to the press that we shouldn't overread the performance. Fair enough. It was the first event of the campaign, so Thompson should be cut some slack. Up to that point, Thompson and his aides had executed a successful three-part rollout of his announcement through a television ad, an appearance on The Tonight Show, and a Web video. (What? No semaphore?) In 18 hours, 188,000 users visited Thompson's Web site, more than Romney's or Giuliani's total for the entire month of July.

But Thompson's aides are selling him as the "Great Communicator" candidate: He is supposed to have the ability to sell conservative principles to the public, which will help him to win the nomination and also will make him the only Republican who appeals to moderates and independents in the general election. So for Thompson's candidacy above all the others, the theater of politics matters, and not just on TV or on the Web.

At Thursday's second and last event, Thompson seemed to find his groove. Standing on a riser in front of his campaign bus in Council Bluffs, he'd shed his tie and replaced his earlier subdued tone with the folksy-joke-shuckin'-small-town boyishness that is his more natural persona. After the first speech, one of his aides had said he wasn't a podium-pounding fist-pumper, and yet there he was pumping his fist in the Council Bluffs town square. The crowd was more than twice the size it had been earlier in the day and twice as receptive. If Thompson can learn that fast throughout the campaign, he might have a shot.

Print This ArticlePRINTDiscuss this in The FrayDISCUSSEmail to a FriendE-MAIL
Share on FacebookPost to MySpace!Share with MixxDigg ThisShare with RedditShare with del.icio.usShare with FurlShare with Ma.gnolia.comShare with SphereShare with Stumble Upon
John Dickerson is Slate's chief political correspondent and author of On Her Trail. He can be reached at .
Photograph of Fred Thompson by Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images. Photograph of Thompson on Slate's home page by AFP/Getty Images.
Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum
What did you think of this article?
POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES

Remarks from the Fray:

Other than face recognition, a half-way decent speaking voice (& delivery), and posturing as a serious Republican, Thompson doesn't have a prayer outside of the primaries.

Could you imagine what Hillary Clinton could do to this guy in a relatively lively debate? He's a washed up politician-turned actor-dipping into the well one more time. He's like John Edwards without the more-focused commitment to politics.

But the real lowdown is that what Fred Thompson "stands for" is only moderately different from what GWBush "stands for" and because of this, no amount of Law & Order re-runs will be able to erase this.

He can't change his platform, seeing as it's about the only thing that gives him a chance at the nomination, but it's also a very fine line. Earlier and in another thread, I wrote that John Edwards won't become President because he's not an engaging candidate and, to a certain extent, because he made his name as a lawyer.

Fred Thompson won't become President because he's a lackluster Republican, and Republicans are going to be quite a bit more scrutinizing this time around. When Fred says "Smaller government, more security" or tries to participate in the Stem Cell debate, he better bring his absolute best.

Does he have it?

No.

Thanks for playing Fred. Maybe get on the horn and keep Sam from getting your L&O gig, as Wikipedia infers will happen should you actually, well, win.

--charming_weasel

(To reply, click here.)

We need a leader.

Reagan slept through his presidency thus allowing the whole Iran-Contra situation and the sale of chemical weapons to Iraq.

Thompson is a good actor. I think we all loved him in Hunt for Red October and of course he has his loyal Law and Order following too......but this is NOT a set-this is real life, and no one will be writing a script.

No doubt Republicans are hoping his quipping will make him a shoe in for president-but the fact is that he is lipstick on the republican pig.

--RML

(To reply, click here.)

(9/13)

Washington Post
The Washington Post
OPINIONS
Over the Line
Harold Ford Jr. | I know what it's like to be smeared by your opponent.
: The Positive in Negative Ads
PLUS » Milbank: The President's Lullaby