HOME / explainer: Answers to your questions about the news.

Will My Plastic Bag Still Be Here in 2507?How scientists figure out how long it takes your trash to decompose.

By Juliet LapidosPosted Wednesday, June 27, 2007, at 6:20 PM ET

Download the MP3 audio version of this story here, or sign up for The Explainer's free daily podcast on iTunes.

How long will those bags last?Starting July 1, most large grocery stores in the state of California will be legally required to recycle plastic shopping bags. In Europe, even stricter anti-plastic measures are gaining traction. Retailers in Modbury, England, for example, recently committed to an outright plastic-bag ban. News reports have cited a statistic that the ubiquitous receptacles take 500 years to break down in landfills. How do we know?

RSS

Actually, we don't. Plastic bags have only been around for about 50 years, so there's no firsthand evidence of their decomposition rate. To make long-term estimates of this sort, scientists often use respirometry tests. The experimenters place a solid waste sample—like a newspaper, banana peel, or plastic bag—in a vessel containing microbe-rich compost, then aerate the mixture. Over the course of several days, microorganisms assimilate the sample bit by bit and produce carbon dioxide; the resultant CO₂ level serves as an indicator of degradation.

Related in Slate

For Slate's Green Challenge, Meaghan O'Neill explains how you can curb your personal CO2 output by saving paper or changing your wardrobe. Sara Dickerman assesses the best garbage cans on the market. Constance Casey examines global warming's impact on your garden. Rose George describes how sewage ends up in the River Thames.

Respirometry tests work perfectly for newspapers and banana peels. (Newspapers take two to five months to biodegrade in a compost heap; banana peels take several days.) But when scientists test generic plastic bags, nothing happens—there's no CO₂ production and no decomposition. Why? The most common type of plastic shopping bag—the kind you get at supermarkets—is made of polyethylene, a man-made polymer that microorganisms don't recognize as food.

So, where does the 500-year statistic come from? Although standard polyethylene bags don't biodegrade, they do photodegrade. When exposed to ultraviolet radiation from sunlight, polyethylene's polymer chains become brittle and start to crack. This suggests that plastic bags will eventually fragment into microscopic granules. As of yet, however, scientists aren't sure how many centuries it takes for the sun to work its magic. That's why certain news sources cite a 500-year estimate while others prefer a more conservative 1,000-year lifespan. According to some plastics experts, all these figures are just another way of saying "a really, really long time."

Sometimes, even banana peels don't decompose once they reach the landfill. For sanitary reasons, modern landfills are lined on the bottom with clay and plastic to keep waste from escaping into the soil and are covered daily with a layer of earth to reduce odor. The landfill, then, acts like a trash tomb—the garbage within receives little air, water, or sunlight. This means that even readily degradable waste objects, including paper and food scraps, are more likely to mummify than decompose.

Got a question about today's news? Ask the Explainer.

Explainer thanks Ramani Narayan of Michigan State University and Charles Moore of the Algalita Marine Research Foundation.

E-MAIL

RECOMMEND... Get Slate RSS Feeds

Juliet Lapidos is a Slate assistant editor.

Photograph of woman carrying bags by Matt Rourke/AP Photo.

COMMENTS

Remarks from the Fray:

I've always wondered, since we burn our current trash, and landfills are getting scarcer, why don't we dig up the landfills and burn that for energy? It seems like it would solve two problems at once.

--ruadog

(To reply, click here.)

While polymers do indeed photodegrade, that doesn't remove it from the environment. The big pieces simply become smaller. This is mostly a minor irritant on land (where microscopic polymers will just become another inorganic component of soil), but poses serious risks to marine life, who can't distinguish indigestible polymer particles from food.

Thus marine organisms starve to death with guts full of styrofoam and PVC. This is bad enough when the creatures eating themselves to death are cuddly critters like sea turtles or pelicans, but as polymers degrade into microscopic bits the effect moves down the food chain, such that these particles are now replacing plankton. You can knock off the top of the food pyramid (turtles and pelicans) with little effect, but let's think really hard about what happens when you kick out the base.

All of which leaves aside the aesthetic issue of areas of ocean the size of continents that consist almost entirely of rafts of plastic garbage.

Polymers will exit the ecosphere when some organism develops the ability to consume it, or if it is removed geologically (through subduction, for example). Burning plastic will break down some of those long polymer chains into more easily-digestible molecules, but release plenty of carbon and molecular goodies like colorants or other chemicals. Garbage bags -- or rather, the indestructible, mildly poisonous molecules in them -- will be around a lot longer than 500 years.

--axoplasm

(To reply, click here.)

(7/3)

What did you think of this article?

Join The Fray: Our Reader Discussion Forum

POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES