
Whose Life Is It, Anyway?My family expects me to care for my mom, even though I have cancer.
Posted Thursday, June 28, 2007, at 7:07 AM ET
Get "Dear Prudence" delivered to your inbox each week; click here to sign up. Please send your questions for publication to . (Questions may be edited.)
Dear Prudence,
I am a middle-aged woman with breast cancer. As a result of treatment, I can't do many of the things I used to do, but I am able to care for my husband and child. My long-term outlook is uncertain, but I'm determined to enjoy life. My widowed mother lives in the same apartment complex. My husband, child, and I took our first trip since my diagnosis, and the time together was especially precious. When we returned, my older brother called and blistered my husband's ear because, as it turns out, my mother had an attack of vertigo and he wanted us to return immediately to take care of her. He believes I should be available 24/7 to care for my mother. I've taken care of her for nine months, through much of my illness, and it's not a workable situation. I need rest to function and don't like to be disturbed after 11 at night. My mother was never a particularly good parent, and we have never been close. She doesn't need nursing care so much as social activity, but she doesn't care for my suggestions. Although I include her in our activities, I can't take her everywhere we go. I did lose my temper with my brother last year during chemotherapy, so my mother feels he's entitled to be angry with me for that, even though I have tried to make amends. In 10 days, I return to work for my husband's family business in another state, a job that will require a lot of travel. May I pass the baton to someone else?
—Worn Out
Dear Worn,
You should feel free to drop the baton. If your brother is so terribly concerned about your mother's care, nothing's stopping him from ensconcing her at his place, where he can give her the kind of round-the-clock monitoring he apparently feels she deserves. Your mother is a difficult, and possibly disturbed, person (borderline personality disorder, anyone?) who has raised a difficult, possibly disturbed son. You didn't need a diagnosis of cancer to be entitled to limit the endless drain of time and energy your mother demands, or the abuse your brother dispenses. But given that you are dealing with your own health and future, save your strength for the family you have made, and move on without guilt.
—Prudie
Dear Prudence,
I'm 28 years old. There's a guy in my circle of friends who I like, and I think he likes me, too. We flirt whenever we're around each other, and I'd like to take it to the next level and ask him out. However, I have no relationship experience. I don't just mean that I'm a virgin; I mean that I've never had a boyfriend. I've never even been kissed. Since I do like this person, I'm a little nervous about pursuing the relationship and having my lack of experience revealed. Should I tell him any of this? I don't want to scare him off with my lack of experience, but I don't want him to think I'm totally pathetic and unskilled, either. What should I do?
—The 28-Year-Old Virgin
Dear 28,
Ask him out, but since you're bound to be nervous, make it as low-key as possible. If your group has a gathering, call and suggest you two drive together, and say you'd love to have coffee and catch up with him before you join the others. If he says yes, after you order your cappuccino, don't blurt out that no man has ever expressed the slightest interest in you or even gotten close enough to kiss you. As you two get to know each other and exchange life stories, the absence of previous boyfriends will be revealed and you can tell the truth—that you're shy around men and you haven't had romances. If things heat up, take a look at The Complete Idiot's Guide to Amazing Sex, and for the time being, stick with the chapter on learning how to kiss. But if he doesn't take you up on your offer and makes no counteroffer of his own, you have to do some investigating. Since you have a group of friends, tell your most trusted ones that you need to make some changes in your life. Explain that you've never had a boyfriend, and you want to know if there's something you're doing that keeps men away. Listen to what they say, make the changes that make sense to you, and put out the word among friends and co-workers that you're on the market.
—Prudie
Dear Prudie,
I am getting married in a few months. We're very lucky that a high percentage of our friends and family will make it to our wedding. This increased the wedding tab a bit, but that's one of the good problems in life. We're having a catered sit-down dinner with two choices: chicken and vegetarian. One couple sent me an e-mail requesting a kosher meal. When I asked whether a vegetarian meal would suffice, they said no, they need a kosher meal that must be prepared by a certified kosher chef. This request bothers me because our caterer will charge us $120 extra for two kosher meals (they have to outsource it), and this couple are not the only ones who have dietary restrictions. We're not making any accommodations for vegans, diabetics, or people with food allergies. Do I just have to suck it up and get the meals in order to be a gracious host, or are guests with special needs supposed to take care of themselves?
—Going Meshuggah
Dear Going,
Thank you for supplying me with a letter about a wedding problem in which the bride is not an out-of-control maniac, but the guests are. Of course, at any large event you're likely to have guests who keep kosher, or eat low-carb, or are allergic to nuts. But what's nuts is when such guests haven't learned how to meet their own dietary needs without causing expense and distress for the hosts. It's one thing to tell the hostess when you accept an invitation to a small dinner party that you can't eat pork, or that a bite of shellfish will send you into shock. It's another to demand a special meal be prepared at a wedding. You can tell your friends that if they're able to bring their own food, you will ask that the kitchen be prepared to plate it for them. Otherwise, you hope the sound of their growling stomachs won't drown out the toasts—OK, don't say that, just say that you hope they'll enjoy themselves at the reception and will be able to eat on their own either before or after.
—Prudie
Dear Prudence,
The other day at a fast-food restaurant, I was lined up at the drive-through when a grandfatherly man and two young boys walked up to my open car window. The man explained that he was from out of town, was visiting his daughter and her new baby, had lost his wallet, and was extremely low on gas. I gave him $20 and he thanked me sincerely, and so did the two boys. As I pulled ahead in line, I saw him give the same pitch to three other customers. If it was a scam—and in hindsight, I see that it probably was—is there some positive way to think about this event, other than accepting that I am a gullible boob?
—Handing Out Cash
Dear Handing,
Think about the poor boys being dragged around by a con man. Maybe your 20 bucks actually went toward food or clothing for them. There are worse things than being kind enough to be taken in by a man using children to get money out of strangers. But if you see him again, don't hesitate to call the police—the authorities should get involved in the welfare of those boys.
—Prudie
News of the World Hush-Money Scandal: How Much Did Rupert Murdoch Know?
Obama's Nominee for NIH Chief Is an Evangelical Christian. And That's OK.
It's Way Too Soon To Call the Stimulus a Failure
I'm Having a Dinner To Celebrate My Divorce
Can the Kid Who Settled Child-Abuse Claims With Michael Jackson Finally Speak Out?
Fake News You Can Dance To











Remarks from the Fray:
I feel moved to share my disappointment regarding Prudie's suggested diagnosis of this gal's mother as someone with Borderline Personality Disorder. "Your mother is a difficult, and possibly disturbed, person (borderline personality disorder, anyone?)"
As a woman diagnosed with BPD, I am hurt to see negative stereotypes perpetuated, especially to such a large audience. This mental illness is horrible; the stigma just adds to the joy.
Lots of people are 'difficult' without having a mental illness. Conversely, I know quite a few people suffering from mental illnesses, including BPD, that are wonderful, caring, considerate, and certainly wouldn't be labeled 'difficult' under most definitions of the term.
Please, let's leave the mental health diagnoses to the professionals. Sometimes a rose is just a rose and an irritating person just simply that...
--starry76
(To reply, click here.)
I wholeheartedly disagree with Prudie's advice here. Do not tell him you are virgin, except for after the fact. [...] If you tell him you are a virgin I can all but guarantee he will run for the hills.
Taking a girl's virginity is serious responsibility as women (and men) invariably have a heavy emotional response to the act. It is often painful and very often creates a permanent emotional bond in the woman's mind with that man. And here's the kicker: Men know this. And here's where things get tricky. If the guy is not interested in being with you forever (odds are) then it is scary to be the one who will forever be your first.
My advice? If he asks you how many partners you've had, tell him you're "not very experienced" or that ladies "never kiss and tell" not mentioning the not-kissing-in-the-first-place part. Then do it and get it out of the way. Then, my dear, you will be free.
--Super90
(To reply, click here.)
I really think you missed the mark on your advice to the bride with Jewish guests requesting a Kosher meal. Kosher dietary laws are not just about not eating pork and shellfish. There are also very specific rules regarding how the meal is to be prepared and the kitchen itself must be inspected and blessed by a Rabbi.
If the guests in question are Orthodox they would be required by their religious beliefs to eat only food prepared in keeping with Kosher dietary laws. I think rather than call the guests demanding I would have advised the Bride to discuss her additional costs with the guests. They might be willing to contribute to the cost of their special needs, if they live in another city or state they may not be aware of just how expensive it is in Kansas for example, to get Kosher because in New York it's much more common.
But I'm not an advice guru- just a Meeting & Event Planner.
--Maggie
(To reply, click here.)
My great-grandmother would always give money to panhandlers. She didn't have much herself, and was always giving what she did have away, often to the chagrin of friends and relatives. Whenever confronted about her overly-generous habits and the bad ones she was likely subsidizing, she would reply that she had done what she needed to be right with her conscience and God. Anything else was between the other person, God and his/her conscience.
The story has stuck with me ever since, and I don't think it would be a bad thing if more people operated on the same principle (I try to, now). After all, we only really have control and responsibility for our own selves in the end.
--Willialm
(To reply, click here.)
The food bank in our old town had a sign on the wall: "If you can afford cigarettes, you don't need our help."
We had a garden when we lived there, which produced more than even our friends and relatives could eat, so we took much of it to the food bank. We let them figure out who was most in need.
I've been a step away from living on the street, and never felt compelled to stand on the street begging for handouts, and certainly not with my kids in tow. When you help them in that way, if they are genuinely needy, you reinforce the message that they are powerless and unable to help themselves. Even walking into a foodbank and requesting a bag of groceries is a positive step someone can make toward regaining their independence and self-esteem, especially since most of those places can connect the needy with organizations designed to help them get back on their feet.
--IncogNeato
(To reply, click here.)
(7/3)