The Movie Club

Every year, Slate's Movie Club brings together film critics to discuss the year in movies. This year, Slate critic Dana Stevens is joined by Carina Chocano (Los Angeles Times), Wesley Morris (Boston Globe), and Keith Phipps (The Onion).

Dana Stevens is Slate's movie critic. You can write her at . Carina Chocano is a movie critic at the Los Angeles Times. Wesley Morris is a movie critic at the Boston Globe. Keith Phipps writes about movies for The A.V. Club, the entertainment section of The Onion.

Who Are These People?

Click to read 10-best movie lists from Dana Stevens, Wesley Morris, Keith Phipps, and Carina Chocano.

Dana, thanks a lot for your clarification, although I'm certain what it clarifies is too complex, and I feel compelled to move away from war. It hasn't been a hit at the box office, and I don't want to know whether Slate will prove any different. But one thing regarding Dana's and Carina's doubt that the further cinematic reproduction of war—under the guise of entertainment or revisionism or whatever—fails to transcend itself or create peace or tell us something new about combat, which is what it seems like you're arguing: We're in different movie theaters, I guess. I don't leave those films happy to be back in the world. I suffer from what I suppose is "returnism," which, simply put, is an escapist's hangover.

PRINTDISCUSSE-MAILRSSRECOMMEND...SINGLE PAGE

FacebookMySpace Mixx Digg Reddit del.icio.us Furl Ma.gnolia SphereStumbleUponCLOSE

Army of Shadows wrecked me, gloomed me up and down, in a way that was the result of both its historical moment (the revolution must have been a nightmare) and my ability to identify with Melville's moving ambivalence toward humanity. The film is about the grueling irony of connection, how these human shadows touch but can never, ever risk stepping too far outside the blackness—or its curtains. I wasn't crazy to think about the wages of current insurgencies while I watched it, either. Anyway, the only reason I'm still typing about this is to wonder how you feel about romantic or sex comedies as analogous to war pictures. They tell us nothing new about love (or sex), either, but when they work, show us how love (and sex) changes people. We might need new lovers (no, we totally need new lovers), but the love, by its very nature, remains the same.

Dana, I sincerely await your thoughts on Babel.

Wesley

PRINTE-MAILRECOMMEND...RSS

FacebookMySpace Mixx Digg Reddit del.icio.us Furl Ma.gnolia SphereStumbleUponCLOSE

Carina Chocano is a movie critic at the Los Angeles Times. Wesley Morris is a film critic for the Boston Globe. Keith Phipps writes about movies for The A.V. Club, the entertainment section of the Onion. Dana Stevens is Slate's movie critic.

Photograph on Slate's home page of Robert Altman by Vince Bucci/Getty Images. Still from Flags of Our Fathers copyright DreamWorks and Warner Bros. Entertainment. All rights reserved. Photograph of couple looking up at marquee on the Slate home page by Patrik Giardino/Corbis.

SPONSORED CONTENT

• The Movie Club
  The greatest Mexican Mennonite film of 2008.
  Jeannette Catsoulis | Jan. 9, 2009
• The Movie Club
  Roach motels and termite art.
  Scott Foundas | Jan. 7, 2008
• The Movie Club
  All she wrote.
  Carina Chocano | Jan. 6, 2007
• Search for more Movie Club, The articles
• Subscribe to the Movie Club, The RSS feed
• View our complete Movie Club, The archive