the breakfast table
columns
- The Supreme Court Breakfast Table
Should there be a shooting range next to the Supreme Court gift shop?
Walter Dellinger
posted June 27, 2008 - The Supreme Court Breakfast Table
Was it ever Miller time?
Dahlia Lithwick
posted June 26, 2008 - What's the Big Secret?
Continuing the conversation.
Patrick Radden Keefe
posted Aug. 30, 2007 - A Supreme Court Conversation
Everything convservatives should abhor.
Walter Dellinger
posted June 29, 2007 - The Midterm Elections
The blame game, George Allen, and more.
Mark Halperin
posted Nov. 3, 2006 - Search for more the breakfast table articles
- Subscribe to the the breakfast table RSS feed
- View our complete the breakfast table archive
A Supreme Court Conversation
to: Walter Dellinger and Charles Fried
Worrying About McAmerica
Updated Friday, June 24, 2005, at 6:41 PM ET

Walter Dellinger is a professor of law at Duke University and a partner in the law firm of O'Melveny & Myers. Charles Fried is a professor of law at Harvard University. He was U.S. solicitor general from 1985 to 1989 and has been a justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court. Dahlia Lithwick is a Slate senior editor. Tim Wu is an associate professor at University of Virginia Law School.
For the last three years, Dahlia Lithwick and Walter Dellinger have weighed in together about the major cases that come down at the end of the Supreme Court term. This year we add Charles Fried and Tim Wu to the mix.
Dear Walter and Charles:
So wonderful to have both of you at the table this year. Welcome.
My thoughts on Kelo echo much of what you've both said: In general, I worry when a majority opinion offers a litany of "it's not as if the government were doing [insert here unspeakably and undeniably corrupt act] …" as its most vigorous justification. Like you—and all the headline writers—I am seriously worried about pretextual seizures and subsequent transfers to McAmerica. That's why I hardly find Justice Stevens' "but the city had a plan" analysis reassuring. So the city had a plan. Who doesn't have a plan?
It's not enough for the majority to assert that this particular transfer was not the product of corruption, which seems to be the nub of Stevens' reasoning. Justice Kennedy does a better job of addressing the cronyism issue—as you note, Walter—but the notion that courts should now start taking allegations of pretextual transfers Awfully Seriously does not seem to have assuaged the fears of the political right. It's hard to blame them.
It is noteworthy that Stevens finds the authority for New London's seizure in a Connecticut statute authorizing eminent domain for economic development. This is not, he is saying, merely deference to a local government, but to the state as well. If you don't want the helicopters, shivering mothers et al., as painted by Walter, move to a state that's not so generous with your private property. Justice O'Connor—in her dissent—finds the majority's deference to be "an abdication of our responsibility." But where O'Connor's bright-line test for deference-versus-abdication lies may well be one of the great mysteries of the millennium.
In the end, I agree that the bright-line rule demanded by the property owners here would be unworkable, for all the reasons you both offer. This seems like the only resolution possible, even though the only folks who are truly happy with it are the good people at Pfizer and assorted city councilors.
Like you both, and much of America, I am on tenterhooks awaiting the Ten Commandments decision, scheduled to come down from the mountaintop on Monday. If Chief Justice Rehnquist could arrange to have a thick cloud and lightning bolts hovering over the court that day, you know he'd do it.
Dahlia
to: Walter Dellinger and Charles Fried
Worrying About McAmerica
Updated Friday, June 24, 2005, at 6:41 PM ETfeedback | about us | help | advertise | newsletters | mobile
User Agreement and Privacy Policy | All rights reserved
Health & Science
Bristol's 17. Why Should Her Mom Get To Decide the Fate of Her Pregnancy?
Arts & Life
The Deep-
Fried Thrills of HBO's Southern Gothic Vampire Show
News & Politics
POW McCain Refused Release. Why Didn't His Captors Just Kick Him Out?
Business & Tech
Want To Save the Planet? Buy a Cover for Your Pool.
- Today's Headlines
- No One On SWAT Team Wants To Wait In Ventilation Duct With Howard
Sat, 06 Sep 2008 09:00:53 -0400 - [audio] Homicidal Surgeon General May Be Hazardous To Your Health
Sat, 06 Sep 2008 01:00:43 -0400 - Evolutionists Flock To Darwin-Shaped Wall Stain
Fri, 05 Sep 2008 09:00:28 -0400 - » More from the Onion
What's Fair Game?Anne E. Kornblut | What questions would Hillary Clinton have to answer if she were in Sarah Palin's shoes?
Editorial: Disappointment '08
- Robert Novak: Fewer Enemies Than I Thought
- Michael Gerson: McCain's Conventional Speech
- Colbert King: Fenty's Unfulfilled Promises
- Ann Telnaes: White Bread and Circuses
- Today's Headlines
- McCain Ally Moves to Curb Probe of Palin
Sat, 06 Sep 2008 01:36:15 GMT - Patti Davis on What Hillary Should Say Now
Fri, 05 Sep 2008 20:32:47 GMT - Gellman: Resisting the Seduction of Eloquence
Fri, 05 Sep 2008 18:56:47 GMT - » More from Newsweek
- Today's Headlines
- Bye-Bye, Boomers
Fri, 5 September 2008 16:44:27 GMT - Living Down to Expectations
Thu, 4 September 2008 21:11:52 GMT - Busted Brand
Thu, 4 September 2008 18:58:59 GMT - » More from The Root

the breakfast table





