Slate's Bizbox
tv club: Talking television.

The Sopranos: Season 4 Analyzed; Week 11

tv club
entries
12345678910111213
from: Margaret Crastnopol
to: Judith Shulevitz, Glen Gabbard, Jodi Kantor, Daniel Menaker, Philip Ringstrom, and Joel Whitebook

Profound Struggle for Self-Worth

Updated Tuesday, Nov. 26, 2002, at 11:59 AM ET

Who are these people?

I find I must beg to differ with Judith and Glen on this one. I don't think Tony quits treatment to forestall a confession—in fact, I don't think he gets much closer to a confession in this therapy session than in any other. He has always spoken elliptically about his darker activities, always flirted with saying more than he should to Jennifer. I think his decision to terminate derives directly from a) his frustration with his own overly impulsive functioning; b) his shame at recognizing Svetlana's insight, that he's a high maintenance crybaby ("sad clown") rather than someone willing to pilot his own ship; and c) that he's re-enacting Svetlana's rejection of him by rejecting the female he respects most, his therapist (see prior seasons for evidence of the latter). Underneath this layer, I think Tony has gotten more deeply in touch with the wastefulness of his existence (if not bemoaning its depravity), and that he is in existential despair, as his dreams suggest.

As for being guilt-driven, I again demur. I believe Tony's guilt is fleeting and of minor proportions. I think instead he's driven by a profound narcissistic struggle for self-worth—which by the way has its own perverse nobility. Moreover, in this episode we find Tony taking on a major life question—the nature of courage, fortitude, or psychic strength. Svetlana defines it one way, Jennifer another, and Tony is trying to carve out his own definition. Against my softer sensibilities (and contrary to my zeal to have him remain in treatment), I have to admire him for that.

Peggy

tv club
entries
12345678910111213
from: Margaret Crastnopol
to: Judith Shulevitz, Glen Gabbard, Jodi Kantor, Daniel Menaker, Philip Ringstrom, and Joel Whitebook

Profound Struggle for Self-Worth

Updated Tuesday, Nov. 26, 2002, at 11:59 AM ET
Print This ArticlePRINTDiscuss this in The FrayDISCUSSEmail to a FriendE-MAIL
Share on FacebookPost to MySpace!Share with MixxDigg ThisShare with RedditShare with del.icio.usShare with FurlShare with Ma.gnolia.comShare with SphereShare with Stumble Upon
Glen O. Gabbard, M.D., is a professor of psychiatry at Baylor College of Medicine and author of The Psychology of The Sopranos, inspired by this discussion. Philip A. Ringstrom, Ph.D., Psy.D., is a senior faculty member at the Institute of Contemporary Psychoanalysis in Los Angeles. Joel Whitebook, Ph.D., is on the faculty of the Columbia Center for Psychoanalytic Training and Research. Margaret Crastnopol, Ph.D., is on the faculty of the Northwest Center for Psychoanalysis. All are practicing therapists as well. Daniel Menaker is the author of The Treatment, a novel about therapy, and is executive editor at HarperCollins. Judith Shulevitz writes the "Close Reader" column for the New York Times Book Review. Jodi Kantor is Slate's New York editor.
Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum
What did you think of this article?
POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES

Notes From The Fray Editor:

Dan Menaker refers to a poster who came up with the masonic theory of the second dream above. That poster is none other than the always-eager liviasghost. (For now, she is liviasghost-2, but we'll work on that.)

Remark From The Fray:

I am still trying to figure this dream out.
Tony appears as a poor Italian immigrant showing up at a mansion to do masonry work.
I thought the figure on the steps was Livia.
I know Tony has told both his kids about the stonemasons who built the church and how much reverence he has for these "foot soldiers" but I still can't put the dream together.

-- liviasghost-2

(To reply, click here.)

(11/25)

Washington Post