Oscars: The Grouch
What a whirl! From utter boredom and dissociation to feel-good, homegrown American melodrama. From the truly sublime to the utterly ridiculous: From Denzel and Sidney Poitier standing, their arms outstretched reaching towards one another, each holding their historic, respective Oscars; to Julia Roberts leaping into Denzel's big moment, blocking his shot. Halle Berry's speech alone displayed the enormous range of emotions, in the immortal words of Dorothy Parker, from A to B. From tears to cringing embarrassment, from awe to yawn. First: "This is not for me, for Dorothy Dandridge, for Lena Horne …" Then: "We've waited 74 years for this, [therefore I get to again] thank my lawyer ..."
PRINT
DISCUSS
E-MAIL
RSS
RECOMMEND...
Facebook
MySpace
Mixx
Digg
Reddit
del.icio.us
Furl
Ma.gnolia
Sphere
StumbleUponThe duality all night was amazing: As noted, Nora's wonderful NY montage, among many other filmed pieces whose meanings escaped me and my friends entirely. Moments of shock: Halle Berry over Sissy. Moments of controversy: Denzel over Russell. Utterly predictable moments: Ron Howard, Akiva Goldsman, Best Picture. There seemed to be an endless series of honorary awards, sucking all the air out of the room. We should edit these considerably.
Though I never would've guessed the top two awards and Many Will Be Surprised, Many Will Purport Not To Be Surprised that the Oscar-race glass ceiling came crashing down on Sidney Poiter's night. In retrospect, Halle Berry was dressed to win. I never saw anything so glamorous in my life. Sissy wouldn't have sold any clothes.
This historic night for Afro-Americans in American film wasn't coordinated. We had no way of knowing about the Poitier award when we voted. I sort of fear for how thought-out it seems, when it was really so random. Except that critical mass has clearly been reached, and the long arm of Sidney Poitier reached from history into the future of film tonight. My son and his friends were not nearly as moved as we grown-ups were; to them, the colorblind, this is all belaboring and celebrating the obvious. Duh. Black movie stars. Yeah, so what?
It's kind of great to see it from both sides now. During Poitier's speech, for a moment all my cynicism melted away. I thought, this is what we do at our best. We can actually change the way people see things. So someday our snotty little kids can tease us when our eyes tear when we hear Sidney Poitier say again, "They call me Mr. Tibbs."
Signing off till tomorrow. A reinvigorated,
Lynda
The Least Fun Thing About Video Games: Friendly Fire
Why Is It Such a Big Deal That We Found Water on the Moon?
A Place So Beautifully Sad, It Makes Me Want To Paint
Help! I Got My Co-Worker's Sister Pregnant!
So Will Harry Reid's Health Reform Bill Ruin Medicare or Not?
The Obama Administration Is Giving This Gitmo Detainee a Raw Deal
Notes From The Fray Editor:
Dira Necessitas said "I love Denzel, but Crowe was robbed" and touched off a long argument. Other topics of interest were Halle Berry's speech (many posts, few defenders), Gwyneth Paltrow's dress (no compliments), and Russell Crowe's choice of roles (one post, strong if slightly wild views).
Reader Comments From The Fray:
See, this is what really depresses me about Hollywood and its movies. Ron Howard makes consistently squishy, feel-good movies that are just next-door-to-really-good enough that he gets Oscars, or is at least a real contender for one. He could put that manipulativeness to work for him and turn out some really brilliant films if he could get rid of the Here Comes the American Hero attitude (I think he played the Opie and Ritchie Cunningham roles too long.) A bit of a darker, more cynical attitude could have boosted several of his films to another level altogether. Imagine Apollo 13 directed by a cross between Howard and David Lynch. Doesn't that sound like a good idea? Actually, given Lynch's films, he would have been a much better choice for director of A Beautiful Mind. We would have gotten a really good view of a schizophrenic mind, I think...
--Kathleen
(To find or answer this post, click here.)
So maybe the Academy gave into some sentimentality and political correctness. So what? If it was the triumph of style, it was not at any great sacrifice to substance. Rather, I think Hollywood brought substance to the rest of us this year with their stylistic choices. Through some partly deserved and partly symbolic gestures, they set an example and gently reminded the rest of us as a society that of which we are capable but have yet to achieve fully. Indeed, in Hollywood at least, the only two remaining groups snubbed by Oscar are wizards and hobbits - and there is always next year!
--The Bell
(To find or answer this post, click here.)
(3/25)