assessment: Taking stock of people and ideas in the news.

W.E.B. Du BoisThe writer who traveled backward.

By David Greenberg
Posted Friday, April 27, 2001, at 8:30 PM ET

Last week David Levering Lewis' biography of W.E.B. Du Bois won a second Pulitzer Prize. Lewis won his first prize in 1994 for Volume 1. This year's prize went to Volume 2. The double whammy recognizes Lewis' gifts as a biographer. But it also reflects the swelling reputation of Lewis' subject—who is now widely seen as the founding father of the modern fight for black equality.

Few people thought that about Du Bois when he died in 1963, at age 95. In the last two years of his life, he had joined the Communist Party, moved to Ghana, and renounced his American citizenship. At his death he was a pariah not just among the establishment powers in his native land, but also, to a degree, among civil rights leaders. While they were gathering for the triumphant 1963 March on Washington, Du Bois was drawing his last breath on the other side of the ocean.

But since his death Du Bois has enjoyed a remarkable rehabilitation. His writings, especially his collection of essays The Souls of Black Folk (1903), have been enshrined, by most reckonings, in that nebulous body of must-read literature known as "the canon." In 1987, the Library of America chose him as the first black writer to merit his own volumes. His ideas underpin much thinking about race in America today. His picture is on a stamp.

William Edward Burghardt Du Bois was born in 1868, in a racially progressive Yankee community in Great Barrington, Mass. He attended all-black Fisk University and then Harvard, where he studied under William James and became the school's first African-American Ph.D.

Du Bois burst into prominence with The Souls of Black Folk, which included a frontal assault on the ideas of Booker T. Washington, the leading black thinker of the day. Washington famously urged black Americans to follow a course of self-reliance and accommodation with white America—to trade or postpone their claims to civil rights for the chance to educate themselves in the practical knowledge that would materially better their lives. Du Bois saw Washington's prescription not only as a bad bargain but also as a corrupt one, which rested on a condescending view of black people's capacities and culture.

The antagonists' positions in that debate have often been simplified as self-help versus integration. Du Bois, however, championed not just integration but integration on blacks' terms—an equality that would not require an African-American "to bleach his Negro soul in a flood of white Americanism." As Du Bois elaborated in The Souls of Black Folk, black Americans possessed a "double consciousness" or identity and did not have to choose between being "American" or "Negro" but existed as both, simultaneously. Long before multiculturalism, Du Bois articulated a way that retaining an ethnic identity and culture did not have to mean sacrificing full status as an American.

Developing that and other ideas from The Souls of Black Folk kept Du Bois busy as an activist and scholar for several decades. Committed to complete racial equality, he helped found the NAACP in 1910, and for roughly 25 years he edited its magazine Crisis. His belief in the richness of black culture placed him at the center of the Harlem Renaissance. His book Black Reconstruction in America (1935) upended then-prevalent notions of the post-Civil War Reconstruction and recast it as a noble action led by freed slaves seizing their rights. Decades later, the white historical establishment came around to endorsing his interpretation.

Du Bois was prickly, often arrogant, and prone to feuds like the one he picked with Washington. In the 1920s he set himself up as the chief rival to Marcus Garvey and his popular back-to-Africa movement. But Du Bois also provoked liberal integrationists. In the 1930s, he fell out with his colleagues in the NAACP, whose campaigns for anti-lynching bills and other measures Du Bois increasingly believed to be too narrow and timid an agenda. Du Bois did not wish to submerge black culture in the fight for equality. He now argued that economic segregation was only evil if it involved discrimination and, sounding a little like Booker T. Washington, claimed that in some cases segregation might serve blacks' economic development.

Du Bois reversed the journey of many intellectuals, growing increasingly radical with age. At a time when many black radicals such as Richard Wright were rejecting communism, Du Bois became more and more orthodox in his Marxism; he even had kind words for Stalin. Targeted by the government as a subversive, he was stripped of his passport and rendered an outcast. Meanwhile, the civil rights movement, under the leadership of the NAACP and Martin Luther King Jr.'s Southern Christian Leadership Conference, was gathering force in its fight against segregation, drawing on the early work, but not the continuing involvement, of Du Bois.

Du Bois has become newly prominent because, despite his geriatric dogmatism, his thinking for most of his life was supple and original enough to reconcile what others saw as contradictions. He espoused African identity and American identity, self-improvement and integration, culture and politics. Today, a bouquet of these philosophies flowers among black thinkers and activists. All of them can trace their roots to Du Bois.

DISCUSS

E-MAIL

Related in Slate

For a discussion of Du Bois and other black intellectuals, read this "Book Club" exchange on Henry Louis Gates' Africana encyclopedia. In this book review, Brent Staples attributes the deterioration of the 1960s civil rights movement partly to the class snobbery exemplified by the bourgeois, fair-skinned Du Bois.

Related on the Web

As part of an exhibit called "The Booker T. Washington Era," the Library of Congress provides excerpts of early NAACP documents. The curators write that Du Bois "favored a strategy of ceaseless agitation and insistent demand for equality." In 1900 Du Bois helped curate a Paris photo exhibition of Negro life in America. To view some of the photos, click here, here, and here. The NAACP hasn't updated the Web site for Crisis in three years. To read some of Du Bois' Crisis editorials, click here. To read about the magazine's role in the Harlem Renaissance, click here. To buy the Library of America's collection of Du Bois' writings, click here. To buy David Levering Lewis' biography, click here (volume 1) and here (volume 2).

David Greenberg, a professor of history and media studies at Rutgers, has two new books out: Presidential Doodles and Calvin Coolidge.

If you liked this Assessment column, check out Backstabbers, Crazed Geniuses, and Animals We Hate, a collection of our all-time funniest, meanest, sweetest, and weirdest profiles.

Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum

What did you think of this article?

POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES

Reader Comments From The Fray:

Greenberg's piece on Dubois has as a sub-caption "the writer who traveled backward." I am curious to know the meaning of this… Is it [because] Du Bois traveled to Ghana, renounced his American citizenship and died over there, and was even buried over there? What Du Bois did should not be surprising since he was always interested in Africa and claimed it to be his fatherland. One doesn't get the impression that Du Bois thought that he was going to "die in exile" if he died in Ghana, as some like to put it. And this tradition continues: his son is a longtime resident of Egypt.

Given his vision and intellect, it would have been better if the sub-caption read: "W.E.B Du Bois--the writer who traveled full circle" or "W.E.B. Dubois--the writer who blazed a forward path."

--Du Fer

(To reply, click here.)

Truth is that the man never went away. Those who study African American intellectual history were always [aware] of the great influence on African American thought and public intellectual activism. Dubois is also known internationally as one of the influential shapers of Pan Africanism. His intellectual give and take with the dynamic Kwame N'Krumah is evident from their writings.

Greenberg claims that DuBois was a pariah during the heyday of the Civil Rights era. How so? The man was very old at the time living in Ghana working on the The Encyclopedia Africana, N'Krumah's project for him--hence his trip to Ghana and his being buried there.

--Du Bois Reader

(To reply, click here.)

(4/30)