What Are Rubber Bullets?
Posted Wednesday, Oct. 4, 2000, at 1:54 PM ETIsraeli soldiers are shooting rubber bullets at Palestinian rioters. Bolivian soldiers shot rubber bullets at farmers protesting the destruction of coca crops last month. Los Angeles police aimed them at anarchists disrupting the Democratic National Convention in August. Just what are rubber bullets, and what are they designed to do?
PRINT
DISCUSS
E-MAIL
RSS
RECOMMEND...
Facebook
MySpace
Mixx
Digg
Reddit
del.icio.us
Furl
Ma.gnolia
Sphere
StumbleUponRubber bullets describe about 75 types of "less than lethal devices" that are designed to deliver a stinging blow that incapacitates but does not kill or penetrate flesh as do regular metal bullets.
The first less-than-lethal bullets appeared in the 1880s when Singapore police shot sawed-off broom handles at rioters. By the 1960s, riot control police in Singapore, Malaysia, and Hong Kong were using more sophisticated wooden bullets. (Wooden bullets still in use today are called "knee-knockers.") British colonists brought the idea back home to England, where they replaced the wood--which could shatter and possibly penetrate--with rubber. Tens of thousands of rounds of rubber bullets were fired by British soldiers at citizens of Northern Ireland starting in the 1970s. By the 1980s the British had switched to more accurate plastic bullets, solid polyvinyl chloride cylinders about 4 inches long and 1 1/2 inches wide. The bullets are supposed to be shot at the lower half of the body; about 19 people have been killed by them in Northern Ireland mostly because of injury to the head. Numerous groups from the European Parliament to Human Rights Watch have called for a ban on plastic bullets.
In response to the Palestinian uprising that started in the late 1980s, the Israeli military developed its own rubber bullets designed to disperse crowds, to injure but not kill. These small rubber-coated metal pellets are supposed to be shot from a distance of about 130 feet and aimed at people's legs. But they can be lethal if shot at the head at closer range, and dozens of Palestinians have died from such injuries. Israeli political scientist Yaron Ezrahi titled his book examining moral conflicts in his country Rubber Bullets.
Rubber bullets were introduced in the United States to quell anti-war and civil rights demonstrators in the 1960s. A fatality in 1971 stopped their use until their reintroduction in the late 1980s. Though famously deployed against recent protesters, they are most often used by individual police officers to subdue armed, mentally ill people. The most common kinds are the bean bag bullet, a cloth pouch with about 40 grams of lead shot that delivers the equivalent of a punch from Mike Tyson, and a plastic cylinder like that used in Northern Ireland. There have been seven known fatalities in the United States and Canada from the weapons.
Next question?
Explainer thanks Major Steve Ijames of the Springfield, Mo., police department. For more on plastic bullets, see the Humans Rights Watch Web site.
What It Will Cost You To Deny Illegal Immigrants Health Insurance
Stupid Drug Story of the Week: NBC's Today Show Discovers Huffing
Can the Government Call God Jesus? What About Allah?
How Twilight Made Goth Fashion Mainstream
Is Disney's The Suite Life Making Your Child Into an Evil Lothario?
The Blind Side: Illegal Use of Sandra Bullock
Reader Comments from The Fray:
[Note from the Fray Editor: Many posters entered The Fray to discuss political or moral--as opposed to factual--issues concerning rubber bullets. Here is a discussion of civil disorder. This thread looks specifically at the Palestinian-Israeli conflicts. And these are some other points:]
As I have heard from a guy who used to serve in the Israeli army, before 1980 they used to use regular bullets. Some of their young soldiers (usually between the ages 18-25) started thinking twice before firing their weapons to protesters (usually kids between 12 to 16). This created a problem for their commanders. The solution? Rubber bullets. The commander can now tell their people to fire their weapons in confidence that no one will get killed. Of course they knew this was not true, but it is easier for a young soldier to think: "I am using a rubber bullet, therefore I can fire without any worry that my bullet could kill a kid". That actually created a whole new problem: because the soldiers now believed their rubber bullets were not lethal they started shooting earlier. So while before they will wait until it was absolutely necessary before shooting, now they will shoot at the most minor provocation.
The rubber bullets are not for the benefit of the protester, they are for the benefit of the soldier, so he can sleep at night after firing at mostly teenagers. I have seen other countries, even the USA, using waterguns. I don't know if that is the answer, but is less lethal for the protesters.
--Mr Ramos
(To reply, click here.)
According to a friend's father--a former Israeli army engineer--Israeli soldiers are trained to fire rubber bullets into the ground, which absorbs much of their force, and to only hit their targets after having ricocheted. Needless to say, training procedures aren't always followed in the field.
--Alex Abramovich
(To reply, click here.)
Police should use paintballs instead of rubber bullets. They don't do much damage, (outside a good welt or bruise) are cheap, and safe. Plus they have the added advantage of marking the violators (by means of the paint that comes out when they hit) so the police can drive around with a paddy wagon and pick up the rioters that were so out of control they had to be shot.
--Billy Joe Jim Bob
(To reply, click here.)
(10/4)