A Job for Anna

A Job for Anna

A Job for Anna

A mostly political weblog.
Nov. 23 2008 4:42 PM

A Job for Anna

Monday, November 24, 2008

  Mark Krikorian is not impressed with likely Homeland Security secretary Janet Napolitano's border-control credentials but concedes

Advertisement

[S]he's about as close as any Democrat governor can get to appearing hawkish on illegal immigration.

"It could mean that the Obama administration picked an immigration person for this job because they want to burnish their pro-enforcement credentials to make a more plausible case for amnesty down the road ...."

That would be shrewd. But I wonder-- suppose it all miraculously works according to plan . That is, suppose Napolitano succeeds, against all expectations, in controlling the border. The ACLU sues to cripple enforcement in the workplace. It loses! Illegal immigration in effect ceases. The public feels soon confident enough to allow Congressional Democrats to legalize those illegals already in the country. No more living in the shadows. Celebrations in the streets! But because the border is controlled, no new illegal immigrants get in. Guest workers, including agricultural workers, do get in--perhaps with a "path to citizenship." But only in the numbers authorized. The question is: Would the Congressional Dems and their allies be happy?

Advertisement

I'm not sure. ... They'd get 12 million new, mainly Latino voters. Likely Democrats. But that would be it. I suspect there are a lot of Dem pols who would not-so-secretly be rooting for things to  not go according to plan--for an amnesty to be accompanied by a breakdown in border control, as it was the last time it was tried, meaning there would be millions more illegal immigrants, mainly Latino, to legalize and empower in future years.. ... 

I suppose the answer would depend on whether the new rules allowed existing immigrants to keep bringing in members of their extended families , thereby rapidly expanding the newly-arrived, legal electorate. ...

I'm not saying this scenario is likely to happen--it's a thought experment. The very forces that might be happy to see the border-control part break down (low-wage employers, pols hoping to surf the Latino surge, anti-nationalist libertarians) would try to make it break down. Which is why it probably would. ... 12:17 P.M.

___________________________

Advertisement

A job for Anna: New York is still in a state of intense speculation on the central policy question regarding Obama's transition: What does it mean for  Vogue? Editor Anna Wintour's "rep" has denied gossip reports  that she'll be joining the administration, but that hasn't stopped them. ... She raised some money  for the campaign. What might she want? Ambassador to France would be a good fit, no? " The French would deal with her a lot better than the Iceberg Lettuce King of Salinas that W. sent over," says cosmopolitan kf reader Madame S. ... 10:50 A.M.

___________________________

Sunday, November 23, 2008

"Franken to Win Recount by 27 Votes": Give Nate Silver points for not playing it safe. ... Update: A new Silver calculation :

Advertisement

The various versions of the model project a Franken win by between 48 and 136 votes once all ballots are re-counted and all challenges are resolved.[E.A.]

There are some disclaimers about high "margins of error." Nobody will notice them if Silver's right. ... 11:22 P.M.

____________________________

Richardson Vets! [ You said this wouldn't happen-ed. Vets for Commerce. That's like being "Hot for D.C."] 1:45 P.M.

___________________________