“You’re heavy,” Ryan Reynold’s character, Guy, tells Emma’s Stone’s teenage counterpart, Eep, early in DreamWorks Animation’s new 3-D feature, The Croods. “Thanks,” Eep gushes. It’s a simple exchange, but it was easily my favorite in this rollicking, prehistoric tale.
Eep is the latest animated heroine to grace our movie screens, and in some ways her debut on Friday will be a feminist victory: Her dense, compact body and swinging, clinging athleticism are a far cry from the skinny Ariels of the past. But The Croods’ progressivism only goes so far. In the end, Prince Charming still holds the glass slipper.
Eep and the rest of her family are modeled after Olympic athletes—swimmers and gymnasts in particular, writer/director Kirk DeMicco said at a press conference in New York City on March 8. “We wanted it to be believable that Eep could live in that time period and that she could climb these rock walls and move like she moved,” DeMicco said when I asked him about the character’s physique.
The problem is Eep’s character doesn't live up to her unconventional looks. She’s no Merida, the beautiful, independent heroine of Pixar’s 2012 film, Brave. When I interviewed Pixar producer Katherine Sarafian about Merida’s mold-breaking mane of curly red hair, she said the character embodied “a new kind of heroine who was trying to determine her own path in life, someone who is not defined by who she ran off and married.”
But Eep, though she is described as “rebellious” and "aspirational" in press materials, can only attain freedom through the slender, shirtless boy who shows up and leads her to it. We get the look of a new female protagonist but the same old Prince Charming story. Guy, for example, introduces her to shoes, fire, and the revolutionary idea that a better tomorrow awaits her.
Along with Eep's dependency, we get her chubby, dumb little brother; a “wild beast” of a little sister; a strong but deferential mother; an overprotective father; and a grandmother who is “ancient, some say, at age 45.” All of them are endearing but not exactly stereotype-shattering.
It’s a shame, because co-writer/director Chris Sanders has said that the higher number of female characters in The Croods means that more could be done with them. But he’s also said that he and DeMicco wanted to indulge in “the dopey caveman world,” as well as work against aspects of it. The characters in The Croods navigate that imaginative world with ease, and I’m not sure how evolved any kids’ flick about Neanderthals needs to be. Still, Ryan Reynolds said he wants Guy to get a shirt if there’s a sequel. I’d like to see Eep get some autonomy.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Irritating Confidante
John Dickerson on Ben Bradlee’s fascinating relationship with John F. Kennedy.
My Father Invented Social Networking at a Girls’ Reform School in the 1930s
Renée Zellweger’s New Face Is Too Real
Sleater-Kinney Was Once America’s Best Rock Band
Can it be again?
The All The President’s Men Scene That Captured Ben Bradlee
Is It Better to Be a Hero Like Batman?
Or an altruist like Bruce Wayne?
Driving in Circles
The autonomous Google car may never actually happen.