Thanks to Christine O’Donnell’s admission that she "dabbled into" witchcraft in her youth, Wiccans are up in arms about their portrayal: One high priestess told the Huffington Post that O’Donnell’s flippant dismissal of her teenage experiment contained "defaming" misrepresentations of Wiccan beliefs. O’Donnell herself blamed it on the era: " Who doesn't regret the '80s, to some extent ?"
In fact, the late '90s and early 2000s were when Wiccanism had its highest pop culture profile: 1996’s The Craft made witchcraft seem sexy and dangerous and darkly appealing to a certain sort of female teenage outsider. That same year, indie darling (and heroine of disaffected teenagers) Winona Ryder starred in a big-screen adaptation of Arthur Miller’s Salem witch-trial play, The Crucible . On Season 4 of Buffy the Vampire Slayer , viewers learned that Willow, a witch-one of many outsiders on a show about outsiders-had joined her campus Wiccan group, right around the same time she came out as a lesbian, part of a larger story arc in which she comes into her adult self (according to resident XX Buffy expert Nina Shen Rastogi). A flurry of books about Wiccanism were published in the '90s and early millennium, including Rocking the Goddess: Campus Wiccanism for the Student Practicioner . And Wiccanism’s focus on the feminine divine-and female-female relationship, whether friendly or sexual-seemed to dovetail nicely with the feminist moment of the '90s .
Hanna thinks O’Donnell’s " Wiccan thing throws a loop into her whole self-presentation ." Not to my eyes: While her dabbling obviously preceded this high-'90s era, I can’t help reading the Wiccan tidbit, along with some of the others, as adding up to a picture of someone who imagines herself an outsider searching to belong to a group. (And who knows, if she’d stuck with it, maybe it’s less likely she’d have become a Republican .) O’Donnell’s Lord of the Rings -as-feminist-text lecture seems to have grown out of a similar strain: For whatever it’s worth, a woman I spoke to at Bryn Mawr (where not long ago it was a relatively common sight to see students in capes), who was a student there in the '90s and is now an administrator, noted that another of the groups closely associated with Wiccanism was a sci-fi-focused group, and another maintained a communal, public diary.
Wiccanism did indeed grow rapidly in the 1990s-about 17-fold, according to the American Religious Identification Survey; but the "New Religion" category of that survey grew even more quickly in the 2000s , based on 2008 data, even if the media and Hollywood are less obessesed with sexy teenage experimenters. Post- Harry Potter , witches (and wizards) are friendly, familiar, kid-safe. Now, if you want dark and sexy, vampires are a classic, reliable bet , especially with female audiences . But there are still college witches , and there’s even a serious pagan community at the U.S. Air Force Academy that recently got its own worship space . Hard data on Wiccan demographics are scarce, but a couple of anecdotal points-the reissue this year of the Wicca Cookbook , the launch of Crone , for the "aging female pagan"-suggest that plenty of people have settled into it as a lifestyle, rather than an adolescent experiment.
I recently noticed a model in a very '90s flashback Urban Outfitters catalog spread holding a book on Wiccanism. And True Blood just introduced a Wiccan character in the midst of all those sexy vampires. So maybe Wiccanism is on the verge of another pop-culture moment, whether actual practitioners-or O'Donnell-like it or not.
Photograph of the spiral pentacle for Wikimedia Commons.
TODAY IN SLATE
One of the most amazing feats in chess history just happened, and no one noticed.
Amazon Is Officially a Gadget Company. Here Are Its Six New Devices.
Do the Celebrities Whose Nude Photos Were Stolen Have a Case Against Apple?
The NFL Explains How It Sees “the Role of the Female”
Amazon Is Now a Gadget Company
How to Order Chinese Food
First, stop thinking of it as “Chinese food.”