Why Constance McMillen's Case Might Not Help Ceara Sturgis

What Women Really Think
Aug. 19 2010 12:08 PM

Why Constance McMillen's Case Might Not Help Ceara Sturgis

/blogs/xx_factor/2010/08/19/why_constance_mcmillens_case_might_not_help_ceara_sturgis/jcr:content/body/slate_image

Less than a month after lesbian student Constance McMillen won her suit against Mississippi's Itawamba County School District for prohibiting her from attending the school's senior prom in a tux with her girlfriend, another lesbian student from Mississippi is suing her school for discrimination. The issue is, again, whether schools can regulate when and where girls wear tuxedos, but this time the venue in question isn't the prom; it's the yearbook. And in terms of their legal defensibility, the two are not equal.

Advertisement

This week ACLU counsel Christine Sun, the same attorney who represented Constance McMillen, filed a complaint [PDF] in the Southern Mississippi U.S. District Court on behalf of Ceara Sturgis, a 2010 graduate of Wesson Attendance Center, the K-12 public school Sturgis has attended her whole life. According to the complaint, in the summer of 2009, Sturgis, who has worn mostly unisex or traditionally male garb since coming out in 9th grade, received permission from a school-appointed photographer to sit for her senior yearbook photo in a tuxedo.

When Sturgis’ mother, Veronica Rodriquez, approached Principal Ronald Greer in the beginning of the 2009-10 school year to make sure the photo would appear in the year book, Greer said no and added, "Tuxes for boys, drapes for girls." Sturgis' mom appealed to Copiah County School District superintendent Robert Holloway, who told her there was no district policy prohibiting girls from appearing in tuxedos in the yearbook, but on the day of the photo submission deadline, a school district employee informed Rodriquez that her daughter's photo would not appear. Principal Greer refused to reconsider. The ACLU sent a letter to the school then, alerting it to the discriminatory nature of the decision, and then bided its time to see whether Sturgis' portrait would appear alongside the other senior portraits. It didn't.

Given Constance McMillen’s victory , on top of many other recent rulings in Southern federal courts defending the rights of LGBT students, Sturgis' case might seem to the lay observer an easy win. But in fact, Sun has her work cut out for her.

In LGBT prom cases, a plaintiff typically asserts that wearing a tux to the prom and/or attending with a female date is a form of self-expression, the right to which is protected under the First Amendment. McMillen prevailed primarily on those grounds. A school yearbook, on the other hand, counts as a school-sponsored student publication and thus isn't considered an entirely public forum. In the 1988 case Hazelwood School District et al. v. Kuhlmeier et al , the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that because the school newspaper at a suburban St. Louis high school was produced as part of a journalism class, it wasn't a public forum, and thus school administrators had the right to censor its content.

Rather than making a First Amendment claim on Sturgis' behalf, Sun is arguing that Wesson Attendance Center violated Sturgis' rights to equal protection under the 14th Amendment and Title IX, which Congress passed in 1972 to enforce the equal protection clause in cases of gender discrimination in an education. "Title IX clearly says school can't discriminate on the basis of sex," said Sun, which includes penalizing individuals for not conforming to gender stereotypes. But this approach, too, is far from airtight. The only specific precedent for it is a 2002 case that was settled out of court and thus couldn't be included in Sturgis' complaint. In 2002, student Nikki Youngblood, represented by the National Center for Lesbian Rights, sued her Florida school district after Robinson High administrators refused to allow her to sit for her senior yearbook photo in a suit and tie. A federal district court dismissed the case, stating that not having your photo appear in the yearbook wasn't dire enough Title IX discrimination to merit legal action. The school agreed to settle and change its policies after Youngblood appealed the dismissal , which means the dismissal remains the only decision on the books in Youngblood .

The major challenge in Sturgis' case then, Sun said in an interview yesterday, is to persuade the court "to recognize that this type of [sex] discrimination is serious and that schools shouldn't be requiring students to conform" to gender stereotypes. "It's quite an uphill battle. Traditionally courts have given a great deal of deference to school districts in how they enforce dress codes." The ACLU will attempt to prove that gendered dress codes do harm outweighing any positive function they might serve. "I honestly don't [see] the legitimate school interest in doing this," Sun said. "I don't think there's a role for the government in telling anybody that women have to be feminine and men have to be masculine, and if you don't conform to that, you're not allowed to participate in this activity that everyone else can." For her part, Sturgis says she is nervous about the case-Sun has conveyed to her the legal obstacles to be overcome. "It's really difficult," Sturgis said yesterday. "I just hope that I win this, and that if I win no one will ever have to go through what I had to go through."

Photo of Constance McMillen by Angela Weiss/Getty Images.

TODAY IN SLATE

War Stories

The Right Target

Why Obama’s airstrikes against ISIS may be more effective than people expect.

The One National Holiday Republicans Hope You Forget

It’s Legal for Obama to Bomb Syria Because He Says It Is

I Stand With Emma Watson on Women’s Rights

Even though I know I’m going to get flak for it.

Should You Recline Your Seat? Two Economists Weigh In.

Doublex

It Is Very, Very Stupid to Compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice

Or, why it is very, very stupid to compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice.

Building a Better Workplace

In Defense of HR

Startups and small businesses shouldn’t skip over a human resources department.

Why Is This Mother in Prison for Helping Her Daughter Get an Abortion?

Politico Wonders Why Gabby Giffords Is So “Ruthless” on Gun Control

Behold
Sept. 23 2014 4:45 PM An Up-Close Look at the U.S.–Mexico Border
  News & Politics
Foreigners
Sept. 23 2014 6:40 PM Coalition of the Presentable Don’t believe the official version. Meet America’s real allies in the fight against ISIS.
  Business
Moneybox
Sept. 23 2014 2:08 PM Home Depot’s Former Lead Security Engineer Had a Legacy of Sabotage
  Life
Outward
Sept. 23 2014 1:57 PM Would a Second Sarkozy Presidency End Marriage Equality in France?
  Double X
The XX Factor
Sept. 23 2014 2:32 PM Politico Asks: Why Is Gabby Giffords So “Ruthless” on Gun Control?
  Slate Plus
Political Gabfest
Sept. 23 2014 3:04 PM Chicago Gabfest How to get your tickets before anyone else.
  Arts
Brow Beat
Sept. 23 2014 8:38 PM “No One in This World” Is One of Kutiman’s Best, Most Impressive Songs
  Technology
Future Tense
Sept. 23 2014 5:36 PM This Climate Change Poem Moved World Leaders to Tears Today
  Health & Science
Science
Sept. 23 2014 4:33 PM Who Deserves Those 4 Inches of Airplane Seat Space? An investigation into the economics of reclining.
  Sports
Sports Nut
Sept. 23 2014 7:27 PM You’re Fired, Roger Goodell If the commissioner gets the ax, the NFL would still need a better justice system. What would that look like?