My Husband Had an Affair. I Fantasize About the Other Woman.

The XX Factor
What Women Really Think
Sept. 23 2009 5:39 PM

My Husband Had an Affair. I Fantasize About the Other Woman.

Here's one response to my question about what role fantasy plays in your life .

I would say that I use sexual fantasies in two separate ways:

1) I use them when I am having sex. I am married and have always been monogamous, and my husband had an affair early in our marriage.  I find myself fantasizing about his having sex with other women when we are having sex.  I would say I do this regularly, probably every time, but the fantasies tend to be brief: mere flashes really. I do not have a good visual memory so I fantasize (and think in general) in "impressions." I also have violent sexual fantasies while having sex, and they tend to be more prevalent when I'm actually aroused (which I would say I am about half the time), and the closer I get to orgasm, the more violent they become, especially if the orgasm is difficult to attain. By "violent," I mean I have rape fantasies where I am being raped (almost always) by a man, and unless I put my husband in that role (rare), the man is always someone I do not know, although in the fantasy he would not necessarily be a stranger. Again, these fantasies are brief, although it's difficult to say how long since the whole thing is very situational. I would say no longer than maybe 20 seconds, although I'll have several in a row or replay the same one over if necessary.

2) I use them when I masturbate. I would say these are pretty similar, although since I am more likely to have an orgasm when I masturbate, and since it's quicker and less intimate, my fantasies tend to "run" quicker in my head (same fantasy, faster show time). I have a few fantasies that are in regular rotation for this purpose, and often I do not think about my husband at all, even to imagine him with another woman, which is (as I said) something I do when we are together.

General comments: I always fantasize at least some when I'm having sex or masturbating. I never fantasize out in the "real world," and I never fantasize about famous people or even people I know (other than regarding my husband as I've otherwise mentioned). Most of my fantasies are modified from a scene I've seen on TV or in a movie, for example, I use the scene from Excalibur where Arthur's father transmutes into the form of another man and has sex with Arthur's mother while wearing bloody armor; and (I'm ashamed to say) the rape scene from The Accused .

In my fantasies, I equate male violence with actual desire. I do not personally like "romance" when it comes to sex. (Rose petals on the bed? Come ON. I'd just think about how I would have to clean them up.) I prefer passion, which I equate with aggression. Not to get all "therapy session" on you, I will say this: My husband's affair was very early in our marriage, and I have always secretly assumed it was because I am inadequate in one or more ways sexually. As a result, when he wants sex, I always assume he wants sex, not sex with me particularly, so I substitute what I feel like I'm missing from him (a genuine desire as evidenced by passion and a lack of control) with fantasy.

Daniel Bergner is the author of the new book What Do Women Want? Follow him on Facebook and Twitter.

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Dec. 19 2014 4:15 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? Staff writer Lily Hay Newman shares what stories intrigued her at the magazine this week.