Voter ID Law Survives in Pennsylvania

Voter ID Law Survives in Pennsylvania

Reporting on Politics and Policy.
Aug. 15 2012 9:16 AM

Voter ID Law Survives in Pennsylvania

Judge Robert Simpson has declined to block Pennsylvania's new voter ID law. I'm only a little bit surprised. Having covered the trial (for a few days), I saw the petitioners (against the law) give a strong case, focusing on the difficulty of getting hundreds of thousands of voters sorted out before a November election. The state based its argument on the 2008 Crawford case, arguing that you couldn't possibly strike down a law just because some voters would be inconvenienced -- voting is inconvenient!

What does the state's win mean, effectively? The ACLU will eventually take its case to the state Supreme Court, which (due to a scandal surrounding one member) is split 3-3, Democratic and Republican members. If the court splits on this law, the Simpson decision is reaffirmed.

When the 70-page decision is available online, it will be up at that link.

Update: Here's the decision. How did the Republican House Majority Leader's boast that the law would help Mitt Romney play out?

Screen shot 2012-08-15 at 9.31.35 AM

David Weigel is a reporter for Bloomberg Politics

  Slate Plus
Dear Prudence
July 29 2015 2:41 PM “If You’ve Got a Good Solution, I’m Going to Steal It for a Future Answer.” Dear Prudence and The Gist follow up with “Creeped Out,” a letter writer with an unfriendly co-worker.