Trump judicial nominee Brett Talley seems to have disparaged Muslims.

Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Disparaged Muslims in Message Board Posts

Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Disparaged Muslims in Message Board Posts

The Slatest has moved! You can find new stories here.
The Slatest
Your News Companion
Nov. 16 2017 5:20 PM

Trump Judicial Nominee Brett Talley Appears to Have Disparaged Muslims in Message Board Posts

Brett Talley
Brett Talley

Matt McClain/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Brett Talley, Donald Trump’s 36-year-old nominee to a federal district court in Alabama, appears to have blogged prolifically on the message board As BuzzFeed has reported, Talley seems to have written about sports, politics, and law under the username BamainBoston, posting more than 3½ times per day. He did not disclose these writings to the Senate Judiciary Committee. BamainBoston defended “the first KKK,” attacked Roe v. Wade, and wrote approvingly of sex between a 20-year-old woman and a 14-year-old boy. He also warned that a disproportionate number of Muslims are terrorists and aligned himself with Trump’s views on Islam.

Mark Joseph Stern Mark Joseph Stern

Mark Joseph Stern covers courts and the law for Slate.

In December 2015, a user posted an article about a pig’s head thrown at the door of a Philadelphia mosque. The conversation quickly descended into Islamophobia; another user wrote, “I would hang him/her in the doorway of the nearest Mosque. That way, every Muslim who comes to pray will see what happens to those who attack and maim/kill innocent civilians.” Someone else then retorted: “We going to be doing this to all terrorists or is it limited to Muslims?” At that point, BamainBoston jumped in:

There’s no comparison between Christians and Muslims when it comes to terrorism. There’s just not. There are terrorists who are Christians, but there is no organized Christian terrorist movement. Today, in countries around the world, the mainstream, dominant sect of Islam preaches the worldwide caliphate and the murder of nonbelievers. Doesn’t mean we should be throwing pigs heads on Mosques, but we should recognize that this is not a lone-wolf issue.

A few months later, in March 2016, BamainBoston weighed in on a discussion over whether Trump could actually “win the presidency.” Explaining “Trump’s appeal,” BamainBoston wrote: “he says what everyone is thinking about Islam but doesn’t want to say.” Weeks earlier, Trump had stated: “I think Islam hates us. … There’s a tremendous hatred. We have to get to the bottom of it. There’s an unbelievable hatred of us.”

If confirmed, Talley will likely hear cases involving Islamophobic discrimination and religious freedom for Muslims. He will also routinely interact with Muslim attorneys, plaintiffs, and defendants, whom he is obligated to treat with neutrality and respect. These comments made by BamainBoston—who is almost certainly Talley—call into question his ability to rule impartially as his office requires.

Find anything noteworthy in BamainBoston's message board posts? Email us at