Henry McCollum and Leon Brown pardoned after DNA exoneration and 30 years in prison.

Scalia’s Favorite Murderer Has Been Pardoned by North Carolina’s Governor

Scalia’s Favorite Murderer Has Been Pardoned by North Carolina’s Governor

The Slatest
Your News Companion
June 5 2015 2:31 PM

N.C. Governor Pardons Brothers Imprisoned Three Decades for Murder They Did Not Commit

464267078-north-carolina-governor-pat-mccrory-holds-a-news
North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory in February in Washington, D.C.

Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory granted pardons of innocence Thursday to Henry McCollum and Leon Brown, two mentally disabled half-brothers exonerated last September of a 1983 murder for which they have served three decades in prison. Superior Court Judge Douglas Sasser last fall ordered the men to be released from death row after DNA evidence implicated another man, and after it became clear that the two had falsely confessed during highly coercive police questioning. As noted in our coverage at the time, the state also declined to test evidence that could have cleared the suspects, and it wasn’t until 2010, when the North Carolina Innocence Inquiry Commission got involved in the case, that the potentially exculpatory evidence was re-examined seriously. At the time of his release, McCollum was North Carolina's longest-serving inmate on death row.

McCollum’s case was personally name-checked by Justice Antonin Scalia in an unrelated death penalty case 20 years ago. In Callins v. Collins, after Justice Harry Blackmun famously announced in a bristling dissent that he would no longer “tinker with the machinery of death” and would never again vote for the death penalty, Justice Scalia specifically cited what he believed to be the horrific facts of McCollum’s case as a better vehicle than the less-grisly facts of Callins for Blackmun to announce his opposition to the death penalty in every instance.. Scalia tartly noted that far more horrific and brutal cases frequently came to the court, writing “for example, the case of an 11-year-old girl raped by four men and then killed by stuffing her panties down her throat. How enviable a quiet death by lethal injection compared with that!”

Advertisement

McCrory took more than nine months to decide to grant the pardons while the two men remained in limbo. The pardons now make each of the two men eligible to receive $750,000 in compensation from the state.

In the coming weeks the Supreme Court will decide whether one of the drugs used in state lethal injection protocols is truly cruel and unusual for purposes of the Eighth Amendment. The machinery of death presses on.

Dahlia Lithwick writes about the courts and the law for Slate, and hosts the podcast Amicus.