The Eye

Here’s What the U.S. 50-State Flag Could Have Looked Like

A book showing a flag with all the stars filling up the whole left and all the stripes filling up the whole right side
Atelier Éditions

The late Robert G. Heft—the man credited with designing the 50-star American flag—was a 17-year-old boy fulfilling a class assignment when he came up with the winning design. The Illustrated America: Old Glory is a new book that features 50 American flag designs submitted by U.S. citizens to President Dwight D. Eisenhower that incorporated Hawaii and Alaska as the 49th and 50th states. [Update, June 30, 2022: As now revealed by Alec Nevala-Lee’s reporting in Slate, Heft’s story was a widely accepted lie.]

A book showing a flag that centers on a map of the United States with the stars within the borders and the stripes radiating out from it
Atelier Éditions
An open book showing a circle of stars with the number 50 written in the middle of it instead of the usual 50 stars
Atelier Éditions
A diagonal stripey situation—the whole thing is made of red and white and blue diagonal stripes, some of them with stars within them
Atelier Éditions
This one looks like a normal flag but with the statue of liberty at the center of a circle of stars
Atelier Éditions

“Old Glory excavates a long-forgotten, yet fascinating chapter from America’s vexillographic history,” said Los Angeles–based publisher Atelier Éditions. The book’s updated renderings of original submitted designs, drawn from plates held in the Eisenhower Presidential Library’s archive, used a lithographic four-color process that represents the era’s printing methods.

This one is weird! It's basically just a bunch of red, white, and blue zigzags knotted together.
Atelier Éditions
Another weird one. It looks like a stripey quilt with a big blue star at the top center
Atelier Éditions
Almost an exact mix of the modern US flag and the modern Puerto Rican flag, with the little triangle coming at the right edge of the usual square
Atelier Éditions

“From the first year of the Eisenhower administration the public had anticipated that Alaska and Hawaii might be added as new states and that a new flag design would be needed,” the library explained in a history of the bureaucratic design selection process on its website.

This one is like the usual 50-star flag but with the logo of the United Nations in place of the 50 stars
Atelier Éditions
This one is like the usual flag, except with exes in place of stars, and the flag seal at the center of the stars
Atelier Éditions
This one is like the usual flag except some of the stars are arranged in a circle
Atelier Éditions

The earliest 50-star flag design submission came in 1953, and by the time that the official design was chosen, more than 3,000 people had sent in their ideas. “The designs came in a wide range of media from simple pencil sketches to professionally constructed flags,” the library said. “This was an especially popular project for elementary school children who expressed their ideas with construction paper, crayons, tempera paint and tiny stick-on stars.”

This looks like the book's inside cover, with an old couple holding up the flag on the left and the words "From sea to shining sea" on the right
Atelier Éditions
A photo of a man gesturing toward many, many possible designs
Atelier Éditions