Matthew Yglesias is on vacation.
What do Americans do when political dysfunction becomes commonplace? Like every other set of not-completely-irrational actors, they adjust. Or they buy a car.
The latter appears to be what analysts are expecting, according to Reuters.
The first government shutdown since 1996 undoubtedly did damage to the economy. A number of companies, from eBay to Walmart, said the shutdown impacted them. According to MoneyWatch, Southwest Airlines’ CFO said the shutdown “cost the company about $20 million in revenue.” For total cost, the number $24 billion has been thrown out a lot. Worse, it did incalculable human damage.
But Reuters is reporting that analysts expect tomorrow’s auto sales to be up 12 percent. Alec Gutierrez explained the somewhat surprising news: “The expectations were that car buyers would wait on the sidelines, but because of pent-up demand and credit availability, car sales are expected to increase 7 percent from last month.”
Weird numbers are a way to make good predictions. One reason is that they avoid meta economic effects. A stock’s price is, of course, less about the value of a company than it is a reflection of what everyone else—that is, the market—thinks the company is worth.
The desire to escape such influences pushes some clever analysts pretty far out. One produces a “vice index” that, he tells the Wall Street Journal, “has an 88 percent correlation to personal consumption figures – and a four-month lead time.” The index incorporates escort services data.
This isn’t to say customer confidence is high. Some context, courtesy of a Bloomberg report from earlier today: “The Bloomberg consumer comfort gauge has declined 9.5 points since Sept. 22. In the period around the first of two 1995-96 government shutdowns, that lasted five days in November 1995, the index fell 5 points. During the second, the measure lost 8 points, half of them in the two weeks after the 21-day shutdown ended Jan. 6, 1996.”
But surveys aren’t as good as real numbers (for those interested, Bloomberg’s methodology is here). Paul Eisenstein is a wonderful person and dug up some relevant numbers from the previous shutdown: “Automakers did feel some impact the last time there was a partial government shutdown – for a week in mid-November 1995 and then from December 16 through January 6, 1996 – sales falling 3.2 percent in December 1995 and 2 percent for the entire year.” That’s a pretty stark contrast from the numbers analysts are hoping for.
If tomorrow’s figures look like the projections, it would shed a lot of light on how Americans are adapting to the still-persisting norm of economic brinksmanship in politics. Since it’s easier to claim you’re uncomfortable than it is to put off buying a truck, I think the latter says more about American confidence.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Right Target
Why Obama’s airstrikes against ISIS may be more effective than people expect.
The One National Holiday Republicans Hope You Forget
It’s Legal for Obama to Bomb Syria Because He Says It Is
I Stand With Emma Watson on Women’s Rights
Even though I know I’m going to get flak for it.
Should You Recline Your Seat? Two Economists Weigh In.
It Is Very, Very Stupid to Compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice
Or, why it is very, very stupid to compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice.
In Defense of HR
Startups and small businesses shouldn’t skip over a human resources department.