Joe Scarborough vs Paul Krugman: CW against economics.
Joe Scarborough's World Versus Economics
A blog about business and economics.
Jan. 29 2013 9:44 AM

Joe Scarborough's World Versus Economics

Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski during the Morning Joe panel at the Winter TCA Tour on Jan, 7, 2012

Photo by Frederick M. Brown/Getty Images

Joe Scarborough's televised debate with Paul Krugman and especially Scarborough's follow-up in Politico is a home run in terms of unintentional comedy. Krugman, as regular readers of his will know, thinks the Beltway conventional wisdom massively overstates the present-day significance of long-term debt and deficit worries. Scarborough refutes this by saying that everyone he has regularly on his show — from Admiral Mike Mullen to veteran diplomat Richard Haas to rich banker Steve Rattner even including his own more liberal co-host Mika Brzezinski — thinks Krugman is wrong.

And it's totally true that by media rules, this is a consensus. Scarborough is a Republican who's reasonable enough to play host on a network with a mostly liberal audience. Brzezinski is a Democrat. Rattner is a Democrat and a businessman who's been tapped for public service. Haas is a moderate Republican. Mullen is, like most successful flag officers, a very prestigious guy in a country where the military is the most widely respected organization and most elites haven't served in uniform.


But of course this is simply what Krugman is saying, namely that there's a very broad and deep consensus among political elites that debt and deficits are a big deal, but it's not grounded in any particular economic insight or theory.

Matthew Yglesias is the executive editor of Vox and author of The Rent Is Too Damn High.

  Slate Plus
Hang Up And Listen
Dec. 1 2015 3:21 PM The “Violating His Amateur Status” Bonus Segment The Hang Up and Listen hosts cover speedcubing—from the algorithms of Rubik’s Cubes to the sport’s record-breaking competitors.