Italy Bans Short-Selling: See No Evil Doesn't Work

The Italian Short-Selling Ban

A blog about business and economics.
July 23 2012 8:45 AM

Italian Regulators Adopt "See No Evil" Approach, Ban Short-Selling on Stock Market

Probably the worst way to restore confidence in the Italian economy is to have financial regulators adopt a panicky ban on short-selling in the stock market.

It is true, yes, that short-selling drives down stock prices, so in some kind of very short-term way, by preventing people from shorting an asset class you can forestall a decline. But that's clearly not a durable practice. It's very logistically difficult to short-sell single-family, owner-occupied housing in the United States, but that hasn't prevented a large decline from the 2005 peak. A stock market, with or without curbs on short-selling, is a much faster moving beast than any housing market has ever been. And as long as the Italian economic outlook looks bleak, the Italian stock market is going to get battered. Amateur hour policymaking doesn't help.

Matthew Yglesias is the executive editor of Vox and author of The Rent Is Too Damn High.

  Slate Plus
Medical Examiner
March 27 2015 5:16 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? Alison Griswold describes her experience reporting on the Germanwings tragedy.