America's Helium Privatization Fiasco

America's Helium Privatization Fiasco

A blog about business and economics.
May 14 2012 2:05 PM

America's Helium Privatization Fiasco

Big blimpin'
Big blimpin'

Photograph by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images.

It sounds funny, but the growing helium crisis in the United States is only partially a laughing matter. The gas is needed for not only party balloons, but also an array of industrial purposes and if we run out it's a problem. Brad Plumer has the story, but it's really just a special case of the all-too-common problem of privatization gone wrong.

To think about privatization it's useful to think about selling something. If you have a bunch of helium and you want to sell it, what you do is sell it to the highest bidder. And if you're a public entity selling some publicly owned assets to private owners, you're privatizing them. So you might think that privatizing a country's helium stockpile would consist of selling the publicly owned helium to private owners at market prices. But in 1996 when Congress decided that the United States did not need a giant strategic helium reserve, Chris Cox, R.-Calif., and his colleagues passed a Helium Privatization Act that ordered the helium supplies to be sold down at a formula-driven price rather than auctioned. That price has turned out to be way below the market rate. That's encouraging overconsumption of helium, discouraging new helium production, and all-in-all creating a big helium shortage.


It's a mess.

But this kind of thing is a problem you see over and over again. One of the big problems with state-owned enterprises is that they often end up being poorly managed. But the same dysfunctional political institutions that produce poorly managed state-owned enterprises all to often also produce poorly managed privatization schemes. That's what we saw in post-Communist Russia, and in a small way we saw it right there with the helium stockpile.

Matthew Yglesias is the executive editor of Vox and author of The Rent Is Too Damn High.

  Slate Plus
Lexicon Valley
March 31 2015 9:17 AM The Redline of March Overheard on email: Slates copy desk rounds up the month’s style and grammar rulings.