Why Cellphone Reception Is So Bad on Amtrak

Moneybox
A blog about business and economics.
April 18 2012 1:44 PM

Michael Bloomberg Won't Solve Tom Friedman's Problem With Dropped Calls on the Acela

113833667
Why does the Acela have such bad Wi-Fi service?

Photograph by Brendan Hoffman/Getty Images for Amtrak

So Tom Friedman wants Michael Bloomberg to run for president in part because "I traveled on the Amtrak Acela, our sorry excuse for a fast train, on which I had so many dropped calls on my cellphone that you’d have thought I was on a remote desert island, not traveling from Washington to New York City."

I've also been annoyed by this, but it's very unclear to me what the political system can do to remedy it. For starters, Amtrak passes through a number of tunnels on this route. Another thing you might notice is that mobile service is generally better if you travel on the cheaper Northeast Regional rather than the Acela, presumably because the somewhat-less-affluent clientel isn't using as much mobile data. And the basic problem is that, to avoid dropping calls along the route, the network has to be able to handle peak-load traffic of a whole train full of prosperous business travels at all points along the route even though any given place only rarely has that many customers in it since the train moves fast. Why don't AT&T, Verizon, Sprint, and T-Mobile invest the kind of funds that would be necessary to deliver that level of service? Well it would cost money. And how many customers could AT&T really poach from Verizon by making this investment? The calculation they've made is that it's a small number, and that calculation seems correct to me. Fundamentally, this is a weird edge case that professional political writers are unusually likely to encounter, and it doesn't make much economic sense for the carriers to address it. I'm not sure what, if anything, a Bloomberg administration could do about it short of a politically implausible plan to tax the heartland in order to subsidize Northeast Corridor mobile phone service.

Advertisement

By contrast, I really do wonder why it's not worthwhile for Amtrak to invest the funds necessary to make their Wi-Fi service reliable. That would cost money, but reliable Wi-Fi service is something you could sell to train riders. If Bloomberg comes up with a plan to make this happen, I'll consider getting behind his campaign.

Matthew Yglesias is the executive editor of Vox and author of The Rent Is Too Damn High.

  Slate Plus
Slate Archives
Nov. 26 2014 12:36 PM Slate Voice: “If It Happened There,” Thanksgiving Edition Josh Keating reads his piece on America’s annual festival pilgrimage.