Rep. Joe Barton (R-Texas) suggests shutting down services that ISIS uses to communicate.

A Congressman Wants to Censor the Internet to Thwart ISIS’ Digital Strategy. Horrible Plan.

A Congressman Wants to Censor the Internet to Thwart ISIS’ Digital Strategy. Horrible Plan.

Future Tense
The Citizen's Guide to the Future
Nov. 18 2015 1:30 PM

A Congressman Wants to Censor the Internet to Thwart ISIS’ Digital Strategy. Horrible Plan.

129219101-house-energy-and-commerce-committees-oversight-and
Joe Barton (left) at a House Energy and Commerce Committee meeting in 2011.

Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Everyone is concerned about how the Islamic State communicates, both in general and to orchestrate violent acts. The attacks in Paris have motivated fresh debates weighing the privacy and safety implications of digital services that encrypt communications but do not provide backdoors for law enforcement. But there is a far less complicated way to deal with both digital propoganda and clandestine communication channels: Shut them down!

The approach seemed to appeal to Rep. Joe Barton, Republican of Texas, on Tuesday during a House Energy and Commerce committee hearing. The Hill reports that Barton asked the Federal Communications Commission, "Isn't there something we can do under existing law to shut those Internet sites down?" He realized that there might be practical challenges to this plan, saying, "I know they pop up like weeds," but the potential First Amendment issues didn't seem to weigh on him until later.

Advertisement

In a statement Tuesday afternoon, the Washington Post reports, Barton explained that he was "in no way suggesting we shut down the Internet." And added, "I am very mindful of privacy and First Amendment issues on the Internet." FCC chairman Tom Wheeler also clarified that the agency doesn't have the authority to shut websites down.

Cutting ISIS off from digital connectivity seems to appeal to some Twitter users, though.

But as commenters in a Hacker News forum point out, "ISIS uses the same infrastructure that innocent people use across multiple countries ... They are not isolated in caves using their own infrastructure." And more generally you can see how it wouldn't be ideologically sound to censor a group that is widely condemned for ... human rights violations like censorship. Quick fixes are alluring, but usually aren't as simple as they seem.

Future Tense is a partnership of SlateNew America, and Arizona State University.