John Brennan email leak more dumb than damaging

CIA Director Email Leak: Not Damaging, Just Dumb

CIA Director Email Leak: Not Damaging, Just Dumb

Future Tense
The Citizen's Guide to the Future
Oct. 21 2015 5:23 PM

CIA Director Email Leak: Not Damaging, Just Dumb

477845429-central-intelligence-agency-director-john-brennan-takes
Central Intelligence Agency Director John Brennan takes questions from the audience after addressing the Council on Foreign Relations, March 11, 2014, in Washington, D.C.

Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Based on what’s been released today, “Crackas With Attitude” seem unlikely to join Edward Snowden and Chelsea Manning among the leakers who’ve had a profound impact on the American national security debate during the Obama administration.

Joshua Keating Joshua Keating

Joshua Keating is a staff writer at Slate focusing on international affairs and author of the forthcoming book, Invisible Countries.

On Wednesday, WikiLeaks published a first selection from the emails in CIA Director John Brennan’s private AOL address. The hacker who accessed the account, who tweets using the handle @phphax, described himself to the New York Post as a high school student critical of U.S. foreign policy, especially support for Israel. He said that he and classmate go by the nickname “Crackas With Attitude” and claimed to have accessed the account by tricking Verizon into providing Brennan’s data and then resetting his password.

Advertisement

A 25-year CIA veteran who once served as Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, station chief, Brennan has been director of the agency since 2013. Before that, he was one of President Obama’s closest and most trusted national security advisers. He’s also courted controversy with his staunch support of the Obama administration’s controversial drone program as well as his defense of Bush-era interrogation tactics, which he has steadfastly not referred to as torture.

But the emails released so far, all of which pre-date Brennan’s appointment as CIA director by several years, shed little new light on these issues. Wikileaks has published Brennan’s 47-page 2008 application for security clearance, which includes personal phone numbers and social security numbers for him and his wife as well as phone numbers for a number of senior national security and intelligence officials. (If you ever want to prank call former CIA Director George Tenet, now’s your chance.) But most of the information on the form could have been gleaned from Brennan’s résumé. (The CIA director has never inhaled, or even consumed, in case you were wondering.)

There’s a fax related to a fairly arcane legal dispute between the CIA and Brennan’s former private employer, the Analysis Corp., which was the subject of some intrigue during the 2008 campaign.* A draft document on priorities for the U.S. intelligence committee recommends that the CIA director be given a fixed 10-year term like the FBI director, something other analysts have also called for. There’s also a memo and draft bill from former Senate Intelligence Committee Vice Chairman Kit Bond on legislation that would limit CIA interrogation methods to those allowed in the U.S. army field manual, something pretty consistent with Bond’s public statements on the issue. 

The most interesting document may be a draft of a set of recommendations about Iran for the new president, written in 2007, presumably during the Obama campaign, to which Brennan was an adviser. He faulted the Bush administration for failing to take opportunities to cooperate with Iran, particularly after the fall of the Taliban in Afghanistan. Brennan recommended that the next administration “tone down the rhetoric” and “establish a dialogue with Tehran,” something his boss has belatedly done.

So far at least, the hackers haven’t caught Brennan in any serious lies or malfeasance. The worst he can be accused of is being careless enough to leave private information on a personal AOL account—which, for a career spy entrusted with what may be the world’s most information-sensitive job, is admittedly pretty bad. 

*Correction, Oct. 22, 2015: This post misidentified the company where Brennan used to work. It is the Analysis Corp., not the Analysis Group.

Future Tense is a partnership of SlateNew America, and Arizona State University.