Bill de Blasio Won the NYC Mayoral Primary Without Sending a Single Piece of Snail Mail

Future Tense
The Citizen's Guide to the Future
Sept. 11 2013 12:43 PM

Bill de Blasio Won the NYC Mayoral Primary Without Sending a Single Piece of Snail Mail

In an enormously popular TV ad, Bill de Blasio's 15-year-old son Dante talked about how the candidate would oppose Michael Bloomberg's "stop-and-frisk" policies.
In an enormously popular TV ad, Bill de Blasio's 15-year-old son Dante talked about how the candidate would oppose the police department's "stop-and-frisk" policies.

Screenshot / YouTube

In the New York Times, Michael Barbaro looks back at how Bill de Blasio went from unknown underdog to the likely next mayor of New York City. (Whether his lead in the Democratic primary is wide enough to avoid a runoff is not yet clear, but he is now the overwhelming frontrunner either way.)

Will Oremus Will Oremus

Will Oremus is Slate's senior technology writer.

The part that’s widely known is that his campaign took off with the help of a wildly popular TV ad featuring his son Dante (see below). Less widely known is how he afforded that TV ad blitz: by cutting corners everywhere else, including salvaging free furniture from Craiglist for the campaign’s “disgusting” Brooklyn headquarters.

Advertisement

The boldest move of all: In the months leading up to the primary, the campaign did not send a single piece of snail mail. Barbaro writes:

Traditionally, New York City candidates pour tens of thousands of dollars into glossy, micro-targeted brochures offering customized appeals to lure groups like Caribbeans, Chinese immigrants and observant Jews to the polls. In July, when the campaign staff met, its members rejected that idea, deciding against sending out a single piece of mail and pouring that money into television — a decision even Mr. de Blasio’s director of mail endorsed, at no small cost to his business.
The penny-pinching worked. Mr. de Blasio accomplished something almost unimaginable in a race in which every candidate abided by the same spending cap: he outspent his nearest competitor by about $200,000 on TV ads.

That might not sound radical to those unfamiliar with modern campaigns. After all, a lot of people are eschewing snail mail these days. But campaigns have been loath to do so, even in the social-media age. That’s not because they like the medium itself, but because, as Barbaro suggests, it’s a way to do what’s known in the business as “microtargeting.” Via mail, you can send messages carefully tailored to small fragments of your constituency without having to worry too much about alienating everyone else.

As Sasha Issenberg chronicled in his book The Victory Lab (and an accompanying Slate blog), ever-more-advanced forms of microtargeting have been critical to recent elections, including Barack Obama’s 2012 victory over Mitt Romney. But that’s not what de Blasio did. His television ads weren’t about piecing together a coalition, block by block, nor about targeting single-issue voters with emotionally loaded attack ads in a bid to puncture his rivals’ coalition. Rather, the “Dante” ad was an example of a very different artifact of present-day media technology: the feel-good viral video.

Future Tense is a partnership of SlateNew America, and Arizona State University.

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Dec. 19 2014 4:15 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? Staff writer Lily Hay Newman shares what stories intrigued her at the magazine this week.