Posted Friday, Feb. 8, 2013, at 1:11 PM
Illustration by Alfred Twu
In the real world, President Obama's grand plans for a national high-speed rail system sputtered out in the face of Republican opposition. But in the alternate world depicted by graphic artist Alfred Twu, we've realized them all, and more.
The map above depicts Twu's vision of an America whose major cities are all connected by state-of-the-art, 220 mph trains. His map isn't strictly based on the Obama administration's actual plans, shown here. It's far more ambitious than that. In short, it's a mass-transit lover's wildest dream. New York to Boston in an hour flat. New York to Los Angeles in a single day. Connections to Vancouver, Toronto, and Monterrey.
I asked Twu via email what prompted him to draw up a map of a system that may never come to be. He responded:
In 2009, the Obama administration released its map of designated high speed rail corridors for federal funding, and there were also many organizations and bloggers that created maps and analysis of where high speed rail should go. At the time, I thought, while these maps were all very well thought out and were great for policy papers, with their gaps and focus on regions and phasing, from a marketing perspective, they lacked elegance and excitement. [So] in 2009 I created the first version of this map, imagining the country as one connected city. ...
More recently, in the fall of 2012, I led a Kickstarter-funded project with a dozen friends to create the California Rail Map, which shows train and bus routes in California. There was a decent amount of sales and coverage for the map, and as we pondered what region to do next, I realized we needed fans outside of California to get a similar map funded for the Northeast. So I dug up the old files for the national high speed rail map, added cities and a time scale. The response has been far above and beyond my wildest expectations as I think it may have touched a raw nerve in the national psyche as four years layer, most of the planned projects from 2009 have fizzled out and California is still a few months away from groundbreaking.
Twu, a committed high-speed rail advocate as well as a graphic designer, has followed up with a WhiteHouse.gov petition to fund a network that looks like the one in his map. The irony, of course, is that the White House already tried to fund a national high-speed rail system, using stimulus money to get things under way. But Republican governors in Florida, Wisconsin, and Ohio refused to accept the money, and Congress scuttled additional funding.
Then again, Twu's proposal is a lot more inspiring than the one the Obama administration outlined. (It's also prettier, and you can buy a copy to put on your wall for $20.)
To me, the greatest fun lies in imagining how snazzy downtown high-speed rail stations might reshape and revive the fortunes of cities like Detroit, Cleveland, and St. Louis. Opponents of mass transit point out that such cities are built around the automobile, not mass transit, and thus lack the density needed to support a high-speed rail system. Proponents tend to agree—but note that cities can change. The federal government today spends more on highways in a single year than it does on Amtrak in 40. Hypothetically, a shift in transportation funding back to rail might spur a 21st-century boom in downtown redevelopment, much as the construction of the highway system spawned the suburbs in the post-World War II era. After all, this map probably looked pretty ambitious to a lot of people too when it was drawn up back in 1955: