In holding that the reach of the Constitution is to be measured functionally, not formally, a majority in Boumediene resolves a question previously muddled by plurality opinions.
Whether U.S. agents must adhere to the U.S. Constitution when acting outside U.S. territory is a question various courts have answered in different ways. As I'd outlined here when Rasul was pending (Pages 295-99), a line of splintered decisions that I've called "maximalist" indicated that the Constitution always constrained agents abroad. A "minimalist" line indicated the opposite, and neither expressly overruled the other.
A close reader of Justice Anthony M. Kennedy's concurrence in one of the latter cases, United States v. Verdugo-Urquidez (1990), might have expected that when give the chance, he would reconcile the two lines with a midway approach; that is, by taking the lead of Justice John Marshall Harlan in Reid v. Covert (1956) (concurrence) and hold that whether the Constitution applied in a particular extraterritorial instance required careful reviews of all the circumstances.
And today, that is exactly what Kennedy did as he wrote for the court that "practical considerations" compelled extension of the constitutional privilege of habeas corpus to noncitizens detainees held at Guantanamo.
Why All the Republican Party’s Presidential Candidates Believe the Same Thing Nearly every nationally prominent Republican politician owes his ideas to Barry Goldwater.
Inside Higher Ed
Criticism Unwelcome The United Arab Emirates blocked an NYU professor who questioned its policies. Is academic freedom at risk?
The XX Factor
Nashville Prosecutors Reportedly Offered Women Plea Bargains in Exchange For Sterilization
The “How Does a U.N. Official Work?” Transcript What’s it like to manage the U.N.’s Ebola response? Read a transcript of Adam Davidson’s conversation with the assistant secretary-general for field support.
“I’d Rather Not Rewrite All the HTTP Stuff Myself” Fascinating early posts from the founders of eBay, Amazon, Google, and others.