In seeking to defend the call for a novel means to prosecute persons suspected of terrorism , Ben deploys phrases like "viable trial regime" and "what we want as a society" and "another legitimate system." He contends that absent adoption of this new-fangled mechanism, "we will consequently put a huge amount of weight on whatever administrative detention apparatus we use as our fail-safe." Packed in that single paragraph are myriad assumptions. But the notions that due-process-lite tribunals can be "legitimate," and that without them "we ... as a society" will have to resort to an "administrative detention apparatus," demand debate, not positing as base-line assumptions.
One need look no further than the Diplock system, invented by our legal progenitor, Britain, to raise immediate questions about the assertion that such tribunals can be legitimate. And as Deborah notes, it's a wonder why more don't look to "the good old-fashioned court-martial ."
As for "administrative detention apparatus," can it be that this is the inevitable fallback? There are doubtless others. As I write in conclusion of Punish or Surveil , in which I measure military commissions against federal criminal courts and ordinary courts-martial, traditionally individuals whom government deems but cannot prove to be a threat were handled outside the criminal justice system, through surveillance . Even today, even with the high detention rates at places like Bagram, this is how most such persons are handled. And even were novel tribunals to be adopted, this would remain the case.
A final question:
If a new form of criminal trial and/or administrative detention are the only options, how have we, as a society whose Constitution is 228 years old, survived without them?
The GOP Base Loves Trump It sees itself in his foreign policy belligerence, anti-elite agitation, and raw bigotry.
A Toxic Legacy Workers like Yvette Flores didn’t know their jobs in electronics manufacturing could harm their children. And the U.S. does tragically little to protect them.
One Thing Primates of Park Avenue Definitely Doesn’t Exaggerate: The Obscene Power of Designer Purses
The Silent Goodbye I might be dying. Should I tell my friends, or spare them the pain of saying farewell?
Geeking Out I write about some of the uglier aspects of humanity. Sometimes escapism is exactly what I need.
Don’t Go in the Water Why a nasty parasite is thriving in chlorinated swimming pools and water parks.