Natural Law or the Legislature, but not the Second Amendment

Slate's blog on legal issues.
March 19 2008 8:34 AM

Natural Law or the Legislature, but not the Second Amendment

Douglas W. Kmiec

Professor Posner is right that -- by originalist lights -- the argument for gun rights belongs in the legislature, not the Court.  Nothing said in the Heller oral argument persuasively demonstrated that the Second Amendment as originally understood protects an individual right of self-defense.  The Court may decide to the contrary, but it will be doing something other than originalism, as Justice Scalia has practiced it.  That said, a right of self-defense, especially in one's home, existed at common law as confirmed by the 1744 case of Mallock v. Eastly ( 87 Eng. Rep. 1370, 1374, 7 Mod. Rep. 482 (C.P. 1744) [viewing the issue as "settled and determined" that "a man may keep a gun for the defence of his house and family . . ."]; and the common law being merely the natural law applied, as the late Edward Corwin elegantly pointed out, there is a natural right of self-preservation.  Professor Posner is mistaken to understand natural law as also supporting a right to disarm to secure public safety.  Whether or not disarming the general public is a good idea is at most a derivative policy choice of the right of self-preservation, not the right itself.  The Second Amendment was designed " to assure the continuation and render possible the effectiveness of" the Militia."  In 1939, Miller treated this as the purpose guiding its construction. ( Miller , 307 U.S. at 178.).   Why Justice Kennedy thinks this "deficient" is unexplained by anything other than the fear of announcing to a portion of the general public that the NRA mailings they have received over the years have been overstated  unless originalism includes the natural law of the Declaration of Independence which is the same natural law of the Ninth and Fourteenth Amendments so well explicated by my Pepperdine colleague Akhil Reed Amar .

Advertisement

A construction of the Second Amendment which assures the existence of militias by guaranteeing the private right to keep and bear arms is entirely consistent with Miller and the language and history of the Second Amendment, but for it to have any application in Heller,   it would require someone in a state militia to assert it, and the existence of a militia that, as I have said in a previous post , is BYOG.    Mr. Heller is neither in a self-arming militia nor in a state, and the Court has no business deciding this case without seriously accepting the premises of natural law originalism which as far as anyone can tell only resonates in the silence of Justice Thomas’ mind, and perhaps, not even there.

 

Maybe if the Court would write out its thinking first, before voting on it , it would grasp that it is error to make the Second Amendment into something it is not.

TODAY IN SLATE

Politics

Meet the New Bosses

How the Republicans would run the Senate.

The U.S. Is So, So Far Behind Europe on Clean Energy

The Government Is Giving Millions of Dollars in Electric-Car Subsidies to the Wrong Drivers

The Best Thing About the People’s Climate March in NYC

Friends Was the Last Purely Pleasurable Sitcom

The Eye

This Whimsical Driverless Car Imagines Transportation in 2059

Medical Examiner

Did America Get Fat by Drinking Diet Soda?  

A high-profile study points the finger at artificial sweeteners.

A Woman Who Escaped the Extreme Babymaking Christian Fundamentalism of Quiverfull

John Oliver Debunks the Miss America Pageant’s Claim That It Gives Out $45 Million in Scholarships

Trending News Channel
Sept. 20 2014 11:13 AM Watch Flashes of Lightning Created in a Lab  
  News & Politics
Over There
Sept. 22 2014 1:29 PM “That’s Called Jim Crow” Philip Gourevitch on America’s hypocritical interventions in Africa.
  Business
Moneybox
Sept. 22 2014 1:37 PM Subprime Loans Are Back! And believe it or not, that’s a good thing.
  Life
Outward
Sept. 22 2014 2:55 PM Nuptial Expert Sarkozy Worries About Gay Marriage and the Family
  Double X
The XX Factor
Sept. 22 2014 12:29 PM Escaping the Extreme Christian Fundamentalism of "Quiverfull"
  Slate Plus
Slate Plus
Sept. 22 2014 1:52 PM Tell Us What You Think About Slate Plus Help us improve our new membership program.
  Arts
Television
Sept. 22 2014 2:12 PM Crusader, Sans Cape The superhero trappings of Gotham are just a clever disguise.
  Technology
Future Tense
Sept. 22 2014 12:14 PM Family Court Rules That You Can Serve Someone With Legal Papers Over Facebook
  Health & Science
Science
Sept. 22 2014 12:15 PM The Changing Face of Climate Change Will the leaders of the People’s Climate March now lead the movement?
  Sports
Sports Nut
Sept. 18 2014 11:42 AM Grandmaster Clash One of the most amazing feats in chess history just happened, and no one noticed.
Politics
Sept. 19 2014 1:51 PMMeet the New BossesHow the Republicans would run the Senate.
Medical Examiner
Sept. 19 2014 5:09 PMDid America Get Fat by Drinking Diet Soda?  A high-profile study points the finger at artificial sweeteners.
Science
Sept. 22 2014 12:15 PMThe Changing Face of Climate ChangeWill the leaders of the People’s Climate March now lead the movement?