Rosen, Ideology, and Rosen's Ideology
Rosen, Ideology, and Rosen's Ideology
Slate's blog on legal issues.
March 16 2008 11:32 PM

Rosen, Ideology, and Rosen's Ideology

Jack noted Jeffrey Rosen's NYT Magazine article, " Supreme Court, Inc. "   Reading it this evening, I noticed a rather curious line:

Ever since the Reagan administration, there had been a divide on the right wing of the court between pragmatic free-market conservatives, who tended to favor business interests, and ideological states-rights conservatives.

This strikes me as a pretty good example of what goes wrong when Rosen tries to force-fit his ideologues-pragmatists view of conservative jurisprudence where it really doesn't work. 

Here, he arbitrarily labels "free-market conservatives" as the "pragmatists" while "states-rights conservatives" are the "ideologues." He offers no justification for those labels, and, indeed, you could just as easily reverse the labels: After all, Justice Holmes famously criticized free-market ideologues on the early-20th-century court , and Justice Brandeis' description of the role of states as our Republic's "laborator[ies]" was, of course, a pragmatic one. 

Ironically, Rosen's own error on this point likely is rooted in ... his ideology. So devoted to his view of Scalia and Thomas, he allowed this sort of error to creep into his analysis.

  Slate Plus
Hang Up And Listen
Feb. 9 2016 1:49 PM The 11th Worst Super Bowl in History How do you measure Super Bowl mediocrity? Slate correspondent Justin Peters stacks them up.