Smores sundae recipe: With strawberry ice cream, chocolate sauce, and graham cracker crumbs.

Can’t Choose Between Ice Cream and S’mores? Make a S’mores Sundae.

Can’t Choose Between Ice Cream and S’mores? Make a S’mores Sundae.

Brow Beat has moved! You can find new stories here.
Brow Beat
Slate's Culture Blog
Aug. 21 2015 8:32 AM

Can’t Choose Between Ice Cream and S’mores? Make a S’mores Sundae.

A strawberry s’mores sundae.

Photo by Alpha Smoot

This post originally appeared on Food52.

No disrespect to the crazy combo ice cream flavors of the world (you know who you are, Mocha Choco Turtle Praline Cherry Funfetti Fiesta), but I like my scoops simple. I want the creamiest vanilla, strongest coffee, richest chocolate, or most delightful green tea your freezer section has to offer. Going with tried-and-true over outrageous means I’m happy down to the last melty drop at the tip of the cone. 


If I do get crazy with my frozen dessert—everyone slips sometimes — it’s inevitably in sundae form. That’s because the toppings get to happen on my terms, in controllable quantities, and once I’ve eaten the cherry and waded through the peanuts layer, I’m back to a bowl of basic. Such manageable risk-taking means I’m not stuck with an entire serving of Peanut Butter Bacon Brownie Passion Fruit Sweet Cream. 

What follows is a recipe for my ideal summertime sundae, because it combines two warm weather favorites. S’mores, even if made indoors over a stove, taste like August nights in my cousins’ backyard, crowded in our still-wet swim suits around their fire pit. And strawberry ice cream is an undeniable force of seasonal perfection. Spring for the good stuff and you’ll be happy to the bottom of the bowl. 

6 ounces semisweet chocolate
½ cup heavy cream
8 marshmallows
1 pint the best strawberry ice cream you can get your hands on
⅔ cup graham cracker crumbs (take out some rage on a sealed plastic bag of crackers until they reach the size you want on your ice cream; I like them somewhere between the Nerds candy and dust) 

Kendra Vaculin writes the Hangry column at Food52.