Thanks to her fondness for the relatively obscure verb to limn, Pulitzer-winning New York Times book critic Michiko Kakutani has been called a “limnphomaniac” and “The First Lady of Limn.” But as New York (and former Slate) music critic Jody Rosen recently pointed out on Twitter, Kakutani has a new favorite cliché: These days, she judges books not by what and how they limn, but just how deeply they are felt.
This tic did not come out of nowhere: Kakutani has been rating books’ deeply feltness for almost three decades now. Nor in the world of book reviews is it exclusive to her. Her colleague Janet Maslin has used the phrase a couple times in the last few years. But Kakutani’s use of the phrase has been accelerating lately at an alarming rate. In the last three years alone, Kakutani has used the phrase at least 19 times, including once (last month) to describe baseball and once just as I was writing this post. If she continues at this rate, 2013 will soon be the most deeply felt year of all time.
Below we’ve rounded up more than 30 years of Kakutani’s “deeply felt” books and people, spanning at least 39 different titles and one baseball player. Please note: We may not have found all of them.
1. The Book Class by Louis Auchincloss: “Mr. Auchincloss implies that such rules were once the glue that held together a stern, but deeply felt system of ethical values.” (July 26, 1984)
2. Family and Friends by Anita Brookner: “In her finest work, in this reader's view, Look at Me, Miss Brookner has used her keen sense of irony to limn this deeply felt, if somewhat limited, theme with clarity and moral vigor….” (Oct. 12, 1985)
3. Half the Way Home: A Memoir of Father and Son by Adam Hochschild “By turns nostalgic and regretful, lyrical and melancholy, Half the Way Home creates a deeply felt portrait of a man and a boy….” (June 21, 1986)
4. Riven Rock by T. Coraghessan Boyle: “Although two powerful stories in his 1989 collection If the River Was Whiskey point to his ability to write about deeply felt emotions, he has thus far failed to explore this territory convincingly in his longer fiction.” (Jan. 20, 1998)
6. Atonement by Ian McEwan. “Indeed Atonement emerges as the author’s most deeply felt novel yet….” (March 7, 2002)
7. Desirable Daughters by Bharati Mukherjee. “A result… is a keenly observed, deeply felt story of familial love and loss….” (April 23, 2002)
8. You Shall Know Our Velocity by Dave Eggers: “There is a similar sense of grief buried deep within Velocity… but it's depicted in such melodramatic, cartoonish terms that it never acquires the deeply felt emotion of the events in Staggering Genius.” (Oct 8, 2002)
9. The Chrysanthemum Palace by Bruce Wagner: “[H]is portrayals of Bertie, Clea and Thad's day-to-day struggles to come to terms with their families’ complicated legacies remain deeply felt and meticulously drawn.” (Feb 22, 2005)
10. Memorial by Bruce Wagner: “[T]he result is a panoramic if sometimes unwieldy novel that showcases Mr. Wagner's ability not only to write savage, often very funny satire, but also to create deeply felt, sympathetic characters….” (Sept 5, 2006)
11. Lark and Termite by Jayne Anne Phillips: “Jayne Anne Phillips’s intricate, deeply felt new novel reverberates with echoes of Faulkner, Woolf, Kerouac, McCullers and Michael Herr’s war reporting….” (Jan 6, 2009)
13. A Gate at the Stairs by Lorrie Moore: “It is a novel that illustrates just how far Ms. Moore has come in the last two and half decades from her keenly observed but jokey 1985 collection of stories, “Self-Help,” which showcased her gifts as a writer but also underscored her—and her characters’—emotional reticence, their reluctance to open themselves to deeply felt experiences.” (Aug. 27, 2009)
16. Pops: A Life of Louis Armstrong by Terry Teachout: “This belief in music as a deeply felt and personal expression is one reason Armstrong avoided using musical terminology when speaking about his work….” (Nov. 23, 2009)
17. True Compass: A Memoir by Edward M. Kennedy: “The late Massachusetts senator writes movingly in this deeply felt autobiography…. “ (Nov. 27, 2009) (This article was co-written with Janet Maslin and Dwight Garner, but presumably the “deeply felt” was from Kakutani, who also reviewed the book separately.)
(Top 10 Books of 2010) “The author’s most deeply felt novel yet….” (Nov. 23, 2010)
23. My Father at 100 by Ron Reagan: “Now, on the occasion of what would have been the former president’s 100th birthday, his youngest son, Ron Reagan, has written a deeply felt memoir….’” (Jan. 27, 2011)
26. The Orphan Master’s Son by Adam Johnson: “Mr. Johnson does an agile job of combining fablelike elements with vivid emotional details to create a story that has both the boldness of a cartoon and the nuance of a deeply felt portrait.” (Jan. 12, 2012)
27. The Newlyweds by Nell Freudenberger: “Unlike her synthetic partnership with George, these are real, complex, deeply felt connections that have both endured and changed over time….” (April 24, 2012)
30. The Casual Vacancy by J.K. Rowling: “The reader can only hope she doesn’t try to flesh out the Muggle world of Pagford in any further volumes, but instead moves on to something more compelling and deeply felt in the future.” (Sept. 27, 2012)
34. The Force of Things: The Marriage of War and Peace by Alexander Stille: “He leaves us … with a deeply felt understanding of how they were shaped by their very different lives and times….” (March 21, 2013)
35. We Need New Names by NoViolet Bulawayo: “’When things fall apart, the children of the land scurry and scatter like birds escaping a burning sky,’ NoViolet Bulawayo writes in her deeply felt and fiercely written debut novel.” (May 15, 2013)
36. The Panopticon by Jenni Fagan: “By its not-that-surprising conclusion, The Panopticon has evolved from a self-conscious debut experiment into a deeply felt and genuinely affecting novel.” (July 15, 2013)
37. Bleeding Edge by Thomas Pynchon: “With the exception of the wonderful title characters in Mason & Dixon, who emerged as deeply felt, genuine human beings, Mr. Pynchon’s people have always verged on the cartoonish….” (Sept. 10, 2013)
38. The Lowland by Jhumpa Lahiri: “What turns this novel around and ultimately seizes the reader’s imagination is Ms. Lahiri’s deeply felt depiction of Subhash’s relationship with Bela….” (Sept. 19, 2013)
39. Mariano Rivera, New York Yankees: “Such outpourings of love are a testament to the intimate and deeply felt karmic relationship that has developed over two decades between Rivera and Yankee fans, and New York City.” (Sept. 28, 2013)
40. The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt. “Ms. Tartt’s theatrical, almost willful dwelling on the gothic in The Secret History has given way here to a deeply felt awareness of mortality and the losses that define the human condition….” (Oct. 7, 2013)
TODAY IN SLATE
Justice Ginsburg’s Crucial Dissent in the Texas Voter ID Case
The Jarring Experience of Watching White Americans Speak Frankly About Race
Here’s Just How Far a Southern Woman May Have to Drive to Get an Abortion
The Most Ingenious Teaching Device Ever Invented
Marvel’s Civil War Is a Far-Right Paranoid Fantasy
It’s also a mess. Can the movies do better?
Sprawl, Decadence, and Environmental Ruin in Nevada
An All-Female Mission to Mars
As a NASA guinea pig, I verified that women would be cheaper to launch than men.