Is the Guy Fawkes Mask Meant to Symoblize Being in the Closet?

Brow Beat
Slate's Culture Blog
Dec. 9 2011 10:36 AM

Is the Guy Fawkes Mask a Metaphor for the Closet?

132924869
Demonstrators wearing Guy Fawkes masks in Sao Paulo, Brazil on November 15, 2011.

Photo by YASUYOSHI CHIBA/AFP/Getty Images

This week in Slate, Rob Walker writes about the surprisingly recognizable branding of hacker group Anonymous. As Walker notes, the 4chan-based group’s public face has become the Guy Fawkes mask from V for Vendetta, which the hacktivists wear as a means of asserting their presence while preserving their anonymity.

Forrest Wickman Forrest Wickman

Forrest Wickman is a Slate staff writer. 

As the article details, Anonymous chose the mask in large part because “it’s available, it’s cheap, and it’s in every city.” Erstwhile Anonymous member Gregg Housh says that the actual Guy Fawkes had “nothing to do with it.” Even so, the mask’s association with the book and the film—in which protesters similarly use the mask to assemble in public and demonstrate anonymously—must have been attractive to some members. While Anonymous members might not be deadly revolutionaries like V, the masks resonate when protesters don them to rally against government corruption, as demonstrators have done at Occupy Wall Street. The mask represents the power of the people, and the power of uniting around an idea, whatever that idea may be.

Advertisement

But in the film, at least, the mask also represents something else: being in the closet. I explain below, but first, a warning: There will be spoilers.

V for Vendetta is set in a post-apocalyptic England ruled by a totalitarian government. The film centers on Evey Hammond, played by Natalie Portman, a young working-class woman who is rescued by V, the masked revolutionary. The original comic book also features a man named Gordon, a small-time criminal who at one point sleeps with Evey. In the movie, however, Gordon becomes Gordon Deitrich, a gay TV host. Rather than sleep with Evey, the movie’s Gordon comes out to her—using the metaphor of a mask. “You wear a mask for so long you forget who you were beneath it,” he explains, discussing his sexuality. (His line also comments on the transformed identity of the film’s masked superhero, V, about whom more below.)

While the film adaptation wants us to associate V with all of the citizens that he’s fighting for (he represents the power of the people, something reinforced by the film’s final image of thousands dressing like him in order to overthrow the government), it takes special pains to associate V with the film’s other gay heroes—especially Deitrich, whom the film parallels with V so closely that even Evey suspects that something is up. One morning, Deitrich makes Evey the same breakfast that V had made her (“eggie in the basket”), gives the same greeting in French (“bonjour mademoiselle”), and plays nearly the same music (each plays a different song by Antonio Carlos Jobim)—and the whole sequence is shot using the same camera angles in the same order.

Evey: This is weird.
Gordon: What?
Evey: The first morning I was with him, he made me eggs just like this.
Gordon: Really?
Evey: I swear.
Gordon: That is a strange coincidence. Although, there's an obvious explanation.
Evey: There is?
Gordon: Yes, Evey. I am V. At last you know the truth. You're stunned, I know. It's hard to believe isn't it, that beneath this wrinkled, well-fed exterior there lies a dangerous killing machine with a fetish for Fawkesian masks. ¡Viva la revolución!

Parallels with other characters are more subtle, but are there nonetheless. A lesbian character named Valerie is shown doing laundry on a steel washboard, while in a different scene (on Deitrich’s TV show, as it happens), V is shown (rather randomly) using the same washboard as a musical instrument. Valerie’s lover, Ruth, grows the same cultivar of roses (“Scarlet Carsons”) that V leaves with his victims.

In the film’s final sequence, which crosscuts between the explosion of Parliament and London’s revolutionaries taking off their masks, five of the last six characters shown removing masks are gay—and all of them are dead. The larger point is that V represents the people (“He was all of us,” Evey says), but the film takes special pains to associate V with these victims in particular.

It seems likely that the Wachowski siblings (who produced and wrote the adaptation) felt a personal connection to some of these themes in the graphic novel, and chose to expand on them in their adaptation. The Wachowskis have long shown interest in representing homosexual protagonists. Their debut film Bound was about two lesbian heroes, and was considered rather groundbreaking for mainstream Hollywood. According to Deadline, they’re also shopping around a screenplay for a “hard R gay love story.” The Wachowski sibling formerly known as Larry Wachowski is now known as Lana Wachowski, and is widely rumored to be a transsexual.

The Wachowskis have spoken very little about the subject with the press, but if this is true then it’s possible that Lana may have felt as V does when he comments that “there’s a face beneath this mask, but it is not me.” (And it may not be a coincidence that as he says this, Antony Hegarty, a self-described transgender singer, sings “Bird Girl” on his jukebox.) In the film we never learn exactly who V is underneath his mask, but it wouldn’t be inconsistent with the above if he were LGBT. (Moore’s graphic novel contains much of the same material about oppressed gays and lesbians—and indeed the earliest incarnation of V was to be a sort of “transsexual terrorist”—but most of the details from the film that I cited above don’t appear in the book.)

It’s unclear what 4chan would think of this. The board may have united against homophobia in the past, but it’s far from politically correct. 4chan users label newcomers as “newfags,” and “-fag” is perhaps the most commonly used suffix on the board. If they’re wearing the mask of Hollywood’s first LGBT superhero, that really is a coincidence.

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Nov. 21 2014 1:38 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? See if you can keep pace with the copy desk, Slate’s most comprehensive reading team.