Greek Deal Makes the Best of a Bad Job

Agenda-Setting Financial Insight.
Feb. 21 2012 11:06 AM

Greek Deal Makes the Best of a Bad Job

139056850
Scaffolding surrounds the Pantheon on the Acropolis on February 16, 2012 in Athens, Greece. Following a meeting yesterday, finance ministers across the Eurozone are calling for greater scrutiny and oversight of Greece's proposed budget cuts.

Photo by Oli Scarff/Getty Images

The Greek deal, hammered out in a marathon overnight negotiating session, makes the best of a bad job. Of course, it would have been better to have bitten the bullet earlier by restructuring Athens’ debt sooner. And Greece is still unlikely to pull through without further economic and political shocks. But the debt restructuring cum 130 billion euro bailout keeps the pressure on Athens and has probably defused a wider blow-up.

Greece, its private creditors and its official creditors are all taking some pain. That’s appropriate. As a foolish borrower, Athens has to reform. As foolish lenders, private investors must suffer a haircut. This will be more severe than expected. The rest of the euro zone made an error in letting Greece into the single currency, turned a blind eye when the country originally got into trouble, and has a strong interest in making sure that contagion to other vulnerable countries is minimised. So it is right to be lending Athens a lot more money on even more generous terms than previously pledged.

Advertisement

But will the deal really get Greece’s debts down to 120 percent of GDP by 2020? With the economy still shrinking and the people nearing the end of what they can tolerate, there is huge scepticism that the country will keep to its side of the bargain. This is heightened by the fact that the lion’s share of the new bailout cash will be paid upfront.

Greece’s official creditors are alive to the danger that Athens will stop playing ball once it has received the money – especially with an election looming in April. They are insisting on further reforms for example, hacking back the public sector – before the first cash is disbursed. They are beefing up the task force that is helping Athens implement the changes as well as strengthening their monitoring of the programme. Greece has also had to agree to amend its constitution so priority is given to servicing its debt. Finally, the leaders of the two main political parties have committed to stick to the deal after the election.

Athens could still wriggle out of this straitjacket, particularly if it can secure a primary budget surplus next year and so will then no longer need cash to run its normal operations. At that point, the government could conceivably say it was stopping interest payments on even the restructured debt.

On the other hand, if Greece really has reached a primary surplus, much of the hard work will have been done. The benefit of reneging on interest payments entirely would have to be weighed against the cost of provoking a massive row with its partners which would then lead it to be turfed out of the euro. An equally likely outcome is that there won’t be a complete breakdown of relations. The programme will just veer off track, the numbers won’t add up, there will be further acrimonious negotiations and the debts will be further restructured. In other words, more of the same.

Read more at Reuters Breakingviews.

Hugo Dixon is the founder and editor of Reuters Breakingviews. Before founding Breakingviews in 1999, Hugo spent 13 years at the Financial Times, the last five as Head of Lex. He began his journalistic career at the Economist.

Neil Unmack is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist based in London. He covers credit markets, hedge funds, and Italy.