-
Posted
Thursday, April 16, 2009 11:23 AM
| By
Dahlia Lithwick
Bonnie—thanks so much for posting on Susan Boyle yesterday. I have to confess I’ve watched her twice, and may well do so daily going forward, or at least whenever I feel the need to smile and cry at the same time. I think you are right to pick up on the fact that the shock of Boyle’s performance brought out a weird vicious honesty in the judges. Even after she had blown them away, they felt comfortable saying—because after all she still looked like Susan Boyle—that she was just too goofy-looking to sing that beautifully.
Now here’s the team from CBS’s Early Show this morning (clip below), insulting her again: Maggie Rodriguez’s patronizing “you look lovely, Susan” starts the interview—the way you might talk to a small child in clown shoes, and she then repeats the question about how Boyle managed to perform “even though everyone was laughing at you?” Co-host Harry Smith, fearing perhaps that Boyle is too provincial to have any cognitive abilities at all, presses her, “Do you understand that? Do you understand what a big deal this is?”
The reason everyone seems to feel the need to insult Susan Boyle to her face all the time is that she looks like a normal 47-year-old woman, and not like Stacey Anderson from The Cougar. That it’s OK to laugh at her for that, and to assume that she should be laughing along with us, makes me want to cry too.
Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum
What did you think of this article?